The staff at Ulysses, Pennsylvania’s Northern Potter High School is giving “Survivor: Palau” a failing grade. The school’s beloved English teacher, Wanda Shirk, was voted off the island during Survivor: Palau's first episode – and her singing may be to blame. The perky 55-year-old sang a few songs to motivate the castaways, but she ended up annoying the group instead. Read what the students and staff at Northern Potter High think about Wanda's singing (yep, she sings at school) and how they feel about her quick elimination from Survivor.