You've seen the news segments and read the articles. The debate is officially on! Do the American Idol
judges go too far when they criticize the horrible singers who walk into the auditions? Do they hit below the belt when they make fun of a person's looks? Do they make you cringe when they crush a wannabe's dreams?
Or do you think people who audition for Randy, Paula, and Simon know what they're getting into? Do you think finger-wagging critics like Rosie O'Donnell need to relax and have a laugh? Hey, Idol fans. Tell me what you think!
Are Randy, Paula, and Simon cruel to contestants?