1. Entertainment

Asia Wins The Search for the Next Doll

By April 24, 2007

Follow me on:

Asia is the winner of The Search for the Next Doll. The teenage mom from Mount Vernon, New York beat contestants Chelsea and Melissa on the show's final episode Tuesday night. The judges agreed that Asia was the best overall performer, even though she wasn't the best vocalist. Asia is now an official member of the hit pop group Pussycat Dolls. She performed with the group for the first time during the finale.

Interestingly, Asia received the least number of votes when I polled readers about who should win The Search for the Next Doll.

Comments

April 24, 2007 at 11:00 pm
(1) Danny says:

Asia should NOT have won. i liked melissa or chelsea.

April 24, 2007 at 11:09 pm
(2) Fannalo says:

AlthougH I really enjoyed Chelsea and Melissa’s performances, I think Asia was the best person to win. Would they really pick someone who had the vocals to replace their lead singer Nicole? They were looking for a back-up person who could shake what they had onstage and Asia proved that she coudl be that person.

April 24, 2007 at 11:14 pm
(3) Mary Ann says:

I agree “Fannalo”

April 24, 2007 at 11:54 pm
(4) joe says:

guuuuuh i hated asia i dont think shes pretty/talented at all chelsea should have won!

April 25, 2007 at 12:32 am
(5) sunDAE says:

I can’t believe Asia’s the winner!She is obviously the least stable person of the three.Asia does not compare vocally to Melissa & Chelsea, although her and Melissa are equally skilled dancers.They should’ve picked Melissa, but she probably too closely resembled their precious Nicole.Asia isn’t a good role model & won’t last long.

April 25, 2007 at 12:47 am
(6) mia says:

i am soo sad.. i wanted MELISSA to win:(

April 25, 2007 at 12:47 am
(7) Pixie says:

Soooooo disappointing! Totally should have been Melissa R!!! Chelsea is awesome and I hope to see her sometime on the pop charts!

April 25, 2007 at 12:51 am
(8) DiaStar says:

Surprise surprise they picked the best person to be a back up dancer! And what’s up with announcing another season?! Melissa would have added greatness to the PCD group. What a shame..

April 25, 2007 at 1:06 am
(9) mariah says:

i SOOOOO AGREE WITH DANNY !!
ASIA SHOULD HAVE NEVER WON !
THEY JUST CHOOSE HER BECAUSE MELISSA WAS ASIAN AND CHELSE DIDNT LOOK LIKE A DOLL ! BUT IM NOT TRYING TO BE RACIST…
AND DID YOU SEE THE WAY SHE TREATED MELISSA ! TALKING ABOUT CUSSING OUT !
D**

April 25, 2007 at 1:06 am
(10) cynthia says:

I’m so happy someone like her won, i could see she wanted it so much and she is the one that needed it. Anyone who really knows talent can see she’s upbeat, strong,sexy and i had fun watching her.

April 25, 2007 at 1:23 am
(11) monica says:

I didn’t like Asia at all. They talk about being “sassy and classy” but she’s neither. She thinks she’s Christina Aguilera by the way she does her vocals and how she holds the mic with her fingers flailing about. It’s true that they wouldn’t have someone with powerful vocals that can overshadow those of Nicole (i.e. Chelsea or Melissa). I just hope her backup-dancer contract only lasts one year.

April 25, 2007 at 1:33 am
(12) Lynda says:

What were the judges thinking! The only finalist with a voice and an incredibly unique look and gorgeous with it was Chelsea. You don’t need them Chelsea…you’ve got what it takes to make it on your own. The other two were absolutely boring – Asia will not attract much of a fan base.

April 25, 2007 at 1:43 am
(13) Robin says:

Way to go girl! You rock. Good-luck on your tour with the other girls.

April 25, 2007 at 1:49 am
(14) ROBIN ANTINISREALLYCHINATHEWRESTLER says:

Big Mistake Robin (aka China)…why would you put a girl in a group who admittedly doesn’t like to be around other girls… because she doesn’t get along wth them and always gets into fights..that makes total sense… I do believe Asia is a performer, but i thought the show was started to possibly find someone to to give credibility to the PCD’s…i guess that was my mistake…at least ALL the Spice Girls had a chance to sing!!

April 25, 2007 at 1:52 am
(15) amanda says:

asia i am glad you won hope your kids relize how much you love them
this will be the most that wonderful thing for you this is prefect for a teenage mom

you are going to be a wonderful role model for other teenage moms

April 25, 2007 at 1:53 am
(16) Stan says:

The most talented person definitely overshadowed the rest of the competition in the finale. There are also intangibles of being in a group, such as a willingness to help others when needed. Chelsea would not have made it as far as she did if Asia had not helped her with her dancing. I personally was more impressed with Asia’s stage presence than Mellisa’s.

April 25, 2007 at 1:56 am
(17) Mel says:

Asia is fierce and hot. She can move and people don’t like her because she’s strong and has her own identity. Not because she has a child she’s not a good role model, that’s ignorant. Goooooo Asia.

April 25, 2007 at 2:23 am
(18) Cris says:

I really thought MELISSA was going to take it…she had all the star qualitys…the looks…the voice…and the girl can dance…I believe they did not choose her because she was a spitten image of NICOLE…

April 25, 2007 at 2:25 am
(19) lonnie says:

I’m glad Asia is the winner. I believe she is her own person and I’m glad that she stood up for herself. Having a baby shouldn’t stop anyone from achieving their dreams. So therefore, I know she’ll be a great role model. On the other hand, I really didn’t like how Melissa S. bad mouthing and teasing Asia throughout the whole show. And guess what Melissa S.? Next time please keep your ignorant comments to yourself. One day you’ll realize what it’s like to have children of your own. Then, you’ll know what it’s like to be a mother. GO ASIA!

April 25, 2007 at 2:31 am
(20) Melissa Fan says:

What it comes down to is the PCD search was looking for a backup dancer and not a star. Melissa R. has more dignity and class than Asia. How does Asia expect to be in a girl group if she can’t and won’t get along with them?? She can try to fake sing as long as she can, but people will figure it out soon enough. Good luck PCD. You’re gonna need it.

April 25, 2007 at 3:13 am
(21) MElissaROCKS! says:

Did anyone know that Asia’s father is a recording artist himself? His name is Joe Bataan. Hmm..funny..they never mentioned that on the show…

April 25, 2007 at 3:56 am
(22) Michelle says:

Congrads Asia you made it Girl!!!
Keep GOD first and Best Wishes

April 25, 2007 at 4:58 am
(23) BiggestFan says:

Chelsea Girl you should have won. Please don’t give up!!! I’ll buy all your albums when you hit it big. I’m your bggest fan!!!

April 25, 2007 at 6:40 am
(24) Errica says:

Congrats to Asia, she was the best performer and no matter what that is what PCD is…people expect that energy on stage and video from them. And as far as her being a role model…being a single mom is hard but she has shown her true inner strength by going for this!! Go Girl!

April 25, 2007 at 7:58 am
(25) A mom says:

I am so delighted Asia won, she indeed is a great performer and works very hard to be the best she can be. I had to watch this with my kids and ended up rooting for all the girls but all in all, Asia is really a STAR performer, she really did show you she is a natural. THAT is what makes her a star, her natural approach.

April 25, 2007 at 7:59 am
(26) Monkeyville_16 says:

Umm, I did not want Asia to win at all. She’s really ignorant and has a baby at what? 18? Umm, okay; Kind of sad. You can tell she’s had sex before.. Oh well, it’s not like all the other PCD members haven’t. Melissa R. should have won; and Chelsea, ahhh, she bothers me. She has a baby face :P Good luck anyways..

April 25, 2007 at 8:30 am
(27) Jackie J. says:

I wanted Chelsea to win because she was a very good singer. Everyone commented on her dancing but you can learn to dance. I didn’t like Melissa because she put Asia down for having a kid didn’t she realize she was doing this for her child. Everyone makes mistakes in life Melissa grow up. Anyway Congrats Asia.

April 25, 2007 at 9:10 am
(28) T says:

Chelsea should’ve won! Asia is too young and too immature. She really needed to be home with her daughter!

April 25, 2007 at 9:13 am
(29) Stephanie says:

When you go on the PCD website they posted another casting call on 4/24…did Asia not work out???

April 25, 2007 at 9:25 am
(30) kenny j. says:

Another thing, people have complained about Asia being whiny over her own child?! Should she have seemed cold and distant,not even showing concern for her daughter?! Which way do you want it…Also what was so wrong with Asia feeling uncomfortable around girls being “phony”. Asia just called it out like she saw it……..
Just proves my point, racism persaudes certain thoughts and attitudes towards people of color.

April 25, 2007 at 10:27 am
(31) anna says:

I didn’t care who won, just as long as Asia didn’t win. But what do i know….

April 25, 2007 at 10:32 am
(32) S M Dean says:

For what Robin was looking for, she made the right choice with Asia. Personally, I really wanted Chelsea to win, but I do think Chelsea has way TOO much talent, looks and sophistication for a group like the PCD’s. With her ingrecible voice, her stunning looks and her extremely sweet and pleasing personality she will go very far on her own.

Good Luck, Gorgeous Chelsea!

April 25, 2007 at 10:32 am
(33) Law & Order says:

Back off girls!
You should stop passing judgments on Asia being a teenage mother. Unlike you, she is strong enough to keep her baby. Having sex is teenagers’ favorite pastime in the U.S. That show is pure sex promotion, and you are all victims of greedy media.

April 25, 2007 at 10:45 am
(34) melissa says:

I liked Asia and I’m glad she won. Chelsea was the best singer and I feel she will be more successful as a solo artist and therefore has a great future ahead of her. I saw the casting call for season 2 on PCD’s website so I wonder if Asia’s job is temporary or are some of the dolls leaving the group one by one. Personally I can easily see Nicole going solo but Asia does not have the voice to replace her.

April 25, 2007 at 10:56 am
(35) amber says:

Chelsea so should have won she was the only one with her own unique look and singing talent,As far as i was concerned alls Asia did was whine about being a single mother and acted like a drama queen all the time get over yourself girl please,We all kno who should have won Go team Chelsea! as usual girl nice girls finish last.

April 25, 2007 at 11:07 am
(36) shellby says:

melissa r. definately should have won. she has the best mix of vocals and dancing. chelsea only has vocals and cant dance, and asia isnt the best at singing.

April 25, 2007 at 11:12 am
(37) Renne says:

I can’t believe Asia won! I wish the PCD luck because they no longer will have my support with Asia there.
If the PCD is to be a team with Asia, I wish them good luck! It will be long and very hard. She seems impossible to get along with and very immature, even though she has a child.

Good for Chelsea and Melissa, they deserve better. Thanks Robin for giving them a better opportunity!

Asia is NOT a role model for anyone. She is now a teenage mother that will never see her daughter. How responsible is that? How can she say she’s doing it for her daughter, I think not, she’s doing it for herself and no one else! Asia’s daughter will not remember her being a PCD, but will remember Grandma being there and not mom! Good for Grandma for taking on Asia’s responsibility as a parent, we are to be there for our children, not worry about fame and money.

Is she the only PCD with a child?

April 25, 2007 at 11:13 am
(38) Jenna says:

OK – somone needs to explain why Asia feels that taking a job that will keep her on the road touring or keep her traveling with priomoting the PCD will be in some way good for her child? If she wanted to do something for her child, she should have tabled her dream, gone to college and gotten a job that pays enough but still allows daily time to raise and nuture her own child. She is very lucky she has people to watch her child and let her pursue her own dreams – but this was not for the kid.

April 25, 2007 at 11:14 am
(39) Jenna says:

OK – somone needs to explain why Asia feels that taking a job that will keep her on the road touring or keep her traveling with priomoting the PCD will be in some way good for her child? If she wanted to do something for her child, she should have tabled her dream, gone to college and gotten a job that pays enough but still allows daily time to raise and nurture her own child. She is very lucky she has people to watch her child and let her pursue her own dreams – but this was not for the kid.

April 25, 2007 at 11:17 am
(40) E.Mason says:

who ever think thaty asia should not have won is dumb…chelsea can’t dance and melissa not the best performer.point blank..good luck asia.kiss kiss lol

April 25, 2007 at 11:41 am
(41) kiki says:

I am very pleased that Asia won. Although I was rooting for Chelsea personally, I was happy to see that the more adult and experienced Asia won over Melissa R. Melissa R. proved to be nothing more than an immature, two-faced ditz who had a big head literally and physically – even though, yeah, she can dance and sing (kind of). And let’s face it, she got cocky and she lost focus. Asia never lost sight of the competition or her determination to win for her daughter. Asia never had to bring someone else down to pull herself up, in fact, she helped Chelsea with her dancing. And for the record, Asia had THE BEST body out of the three of them and I am so glad that Asia put that phony biatch Melissa R. in her place!!! Sucka!

Congratulations Asia!

April 25, 2007 at 11:53 am
(42) shauncey says:

Asia was the best person to win. So she has had sex and had a baby, so what? That was an ignorant comment. So I guess you think all the PCD’s are virgins?? Dream on. I don’t think Melissa R.’s parents would’ve supported her and she would of end up quitting due to their expectations. I loved Chelsea and hope to see her make it. But Asia, you go girl! I knew you were going to win! Show the world what you can do and take care of your beautiful daughter. Don’t listen to these haters!

April 25, 2007 at 12:02 pm
(43) kenny j. says:

After reviewing many comments, it proves my point. We still live in a racist, sexist society. Why are so many persauded to think negatively of a person of color who becomes successful? All of the 3 finalists had their own unique strengths and weaknesses. However, the judges chose…Asia,and had reason to believe that she has strong potential. Why paint a picture of her as useless, loosely moraled, and unglamorous? Are the PSD’s all outstanding,highly moraled model citizens themselves? People, you do not know what kind of skeletons all these women have!Also,it is not surprising that people who allow racism to cloud their judgment, would favor Chelsea. She is the all American White girl. Many of you seem to exaggerate her abilities. As far as Asia being a mom, what about all these successful entertainers always on the road:The Dixie Chicks, Christina Ag., Kelly Rippa, etc. Do you guys not support them? They are all mothers as well..

April 25, 2007 at 12:02 pm
(44) amanda says:

I CAN’T BELIEVE SHE WON
i’ll just pretend she’s not there
the next time i see PCD in concert
i’ll still by their next album but
again i’ll pretend asia isn’t there :]

April 25, 2007 at 12:11 pm
(45) kenny j. says:

Again,racism clouding people’s attitudes and judgments….
These judges are highly qualified, esp. the founder of the PCD’s.
They chose Asia for a reason. Unfortunately, your negative opinions will not be able to undermine the PCD latest addition. Some of you unfortunately have a hard time supporting anyone of color.

April 25, 2007 at 12:21 pm
(46) janella says:

Go Asia- Everybody that thinks you should not have won are haters!!!!, we do live in a racist society and they are the ones that are hating on you but what God has for you it is for you!! You were the real one on the show I wish the best and much success because the people who did not won’t you to win are haters!! but thats ok SHE STILL WON!!!!! GET OVER IT HATERS!!!!!!!!!!!

April 25, 2007 at 12:42 pm
(47) Charlene says:

OMG!!! What’s with all the racist talk?!?! It’s not like we didn’t like Asia because she is black! She just isn’t as great as the other girls are! I was hoping Chelsea would have won…She has a unique style and an awesome voice! Being a different color has nothing to do about it! Gosh, people have nothing better to do, than to pull the racist plug!

April 25, 2007 at 12:49 pm
(48) jamila hikcman says:

I am so happy that Asia won the Search. She can sang and dance and when they performed she did the best of all 3. All 3 gyrls were very talented but Asia had what it took to be the next doll. So to all the hatas out there stop hatin on Asia. By the way just because Asia is 18 with a baby that doesn’t mean a thing because there are gyrls out there having babies at the age of 13. Congrats Asia. Stay strong and don’t worry about the negative things that others say. Stay true and do what you do best, which is sing,dance and be a good role model for me and other 18 years .

April 25, 2007 at 12:55 pm
(49) nancy says:

I totally beleive that Asia should not have won. I would think that the PCD would want to have a likable person in their group, which Asia is not. She is not a team player at all. I was hoping the Chelsea would win, but I hope this has opened some doors for her.

April 25, 2007 at 1:00 pm
(50) kenny j. says:

The reason why I have pointed out racism is the fact that if Asia was untalented, not beautiful, had potential, why would she be there? I have read very negative comments about her. Not many want to support her and really look at what she has to offer the group! Again, why are people so focused on Chelsea or the other girl? Why are they so hyped up to seem much more talented than the winner….
Could it be racism?…….
But of course, I forgot,many racists are in denial.
Most of you are unwilling to support Asia, with all her strengths, weaknesses, and beauty. You just want to sit around and pout about poor little All American White girl Chelsea not making the cut! Personally, I thought Chelsea was cute and sweet, but downright boring. As far as her style and look being unique, unique in what way? She looked like a typical Caucasian girl next door with no flavor. Asia represents the exotic. Most of you probably dislike her because you feel threatened by her talent and unique gene pool. She is just a unique individual. Also remember she will have some weaknesses to work through, she is only 18!

April 25, 2007 at 1:04 pm
(51) Miss Smith says:

Stop all the hating. All three girls did a terrific job, Asia just performed better than the rest. Accept it, it was a chance of a lifetime and they made it really far. Maybe we will see the others in a solo act soon!

April 25, 2007 at 1:14 pm
(52) Dee says:

go Asia go go go.don’t worry about all these haters didnt yall know haters never win all yall do is playa hate

April 25, 2007 at 1:21 pm
(53) kenny j. says:

That’s right! Stop hating and being so outraged to see Asia as a new addition. One or two of you have commented that you will no longer support the PCD’s or look in her direction if you were to go to their concert. How pathetic. Its a group show! Many of the original PCD’s probably had to go through many trials and triumphs when originating and making the group as a whole successful. Asia has the ability to do the same. Again, it shows America’s contempt for people of color, esp. the ones that want to pursue their dreams and become rich and successful. If the other girls are so talented as many of you have said, they will be successful on their own! Their presumed talents will serve them justice……

April 25, 2007 at 1:26 pm
(54) amanda says:

I DONT THINK ASIA SHOULD HAVE WON THIS AT ALL! HER VOCALS WERE NOT STRONG …AND SHE HAD THE WORST ATTITUDE! AND IT DOESNT HELP SHE HAS A CHILD NOT THAT YOU CANT TAKE CARE OF A CHILD AND WORK…BUT THIS IS A DIFFERNT LINE OF BUSINESS..ITS A 24-7 JOB! I DONT THINK SHE WILL LAST LONG! AND I FEEL PERSONALLY THAT MELISSA R SHOULD HAVE WON THIS …NO DOUBT

April 25, 2007 at 1:36 pm
(55) devie b. says:

MELISSA Rocks!!!!!goood luck girl this is just the beginning….loveu!

April 25, 2007 at 1:39 pm
(56) kenny j. says:

Blah, blah, blah Amanda….
However you feel, Asia won and was selected by judges with credentials and experience in the music and entertainment industry. As far as bringing her child into the picture, what about all the other celebrities(including actors,singers,tv personalities)who have to work hard. Many of them have children. I don’t see that many people being outraged over Kelly Rippa on Regis and Kelly, who is an everyday working celebrity mom of 2-4 children! You seem very disillusioned and eager to paint an ugly picture of Asia. I think I know why though…..
Also, keep in mind that many celebrities do put in much time, effort, and energy into their crafts, but they also have readily access to travel with private jets, exclusive first class flying on any airline, etc.

April 25, 2007 at 1:49 pm
(57) miss says:

it’s true: ASIA DANCES LIKE A DRAG QUEEN. She’s very awkward on stage with her man-legs planted 3 feet apart, that pained look on her face, and those annoying fluttering fingers on the mic. she’s as clueless and disconnected about other people and friendships as she is about being on stage.
she goes and yells at melissa for being “fake” because she doesn’t understand that Yah, friends annoy other friends – happens all the time. it’s not tragic. and how does Asia react? by pretending to be ‘best friends’ with Melissa at rehersals, aka: BEING FAKE. she’s got about 4 years to reach the maturity of an average 18 year old. i’m sure her daughter will really reap all the benefits of her mom being away on tour as a mute backup dancer for one year, and then reaching an early washed-up “career” by 22.

April 25, 2007 at 1:57 pm
(58) Belinda says:

Chelsea can go win American Idol now!
Melissa looked too much like Nicole–absolutely drop dead gorgeous! Thats why they couldn;t pick her!
I personally wanted anyone but Asia to win but whatever!

April 25, 2007 at 2:13 pm
(59) Charlene says:

I think that kenny j. needs to find another hobby, other than calling people racist…we are just here to express our opinions, not to have an online debate…

April 25, 2007 at 2:20 pm
(60) daphnee says:

asia deserved it. im glad and happy for her. you go girl

April 25, 2007 at 2:55 pm
(61) Stacie says:

Asia should have not won,she thinks she is a dive at 18,she has alot of growing up to do,didnt they watch her fighting? Chelsea looks ,sings and acts like a true doll! I hope she trys out next year! Love ya Chelsea!!

April 25, 2007 at 3:01 pm
(62) kayla says:

i like asia but chelsea better i was hopeing she would win i hate melisa.r. she think she all good but she’s nothing but a fake so haha for all the girl that like and i hate her that fake bitch

April 25, 2007 at 3:06 pm
(63) Angela says:

I agree with Stacie,I think she meant diva,Asia should be a mom first,remember when she would not eat what the other girls were eating? Melissa or Chelsea should definetly be discovered,Chelsea though was so adorable and took all the crap they other girls dished out!! LOL

April 25, 2007 at 3:08 pm
(64) the bitch next door says:

u guys need to get a life—especially kenny!!!!

asia is black, melissa r is asian, and chelsea is white–aint nobody was judged because of their race!!!!

if anyone is clouded by racism it would be those people who first noticed it…

as for my comment—asia’s hand movement was definitely annoying– if chelsea was a better dancer–i would have definitely picked her. Melissa r didnt give out that sexy vibe!..

April 25, 2007 at 3:14 pm
(65) kenny j. says:

Whatever you guys say. I will go get a life and end here, but you need to do the same as well………
But whatever your opinions may be, Asia is the new winner and there is nothing any of you can do about……
Peace……….

April 25, 2007 at 4:07 pm
(66) Namyanka says:

Asia winning and your ignorant reviews just shows us that racism is still in the air. So what she is a teenage mom. How many other entertainers, actors, actress, and government officials have children that they are not around 24/7. Do we bash them or stop watching television, movies, news, etc. or anything that concerns their jobs. NO! So next time don’t mention her being a teenage mom without mentioning the rich sending their children to boarding schools, children drinking like true alcholics, children needing rehab so early in life for an addiction, and let’s not forget the teenagers engaging in more drug activity than the average pharmaceutical company. I’m just saying more celebrities and government officials have more problems with their children than an average hardworking parent. I’m not a teenage mom nor am I african american but a realistic person. So maybe the real reason she’s disliked only boils down to two reasons: She’s african american with a child.

April 25, 2007 at 4:23 pm
(67) Pat says:

Asia nothing special take her booty away and she will be history

April 25, 2007 at 5:04 pm
(68) Amy says:

The show is rigged anyways. Asia was already chosen from the beginning. If you want to be a PCD backup singer, you cannot outdo Nicole. Asia was perfect cuz she’s ugly & can’t sing just like the rest of the backup singers. If Melissa R. wins, she’s competition. Melissa is better as a solo artist anyways. She’s too good to be a PCD. Good luck to the future of the PCD. Robin just killed her group.

April 25, 2007 at 5:09 pm
(69) dashawn says:

asia is the best on that show i dont care what any body said asia you had rock it

April 25, 2007 at 6:20 pm
(70) aaa says:

aa

April 25, 2007 at 6:45 pm
(71) yolanda says:

I never knew there were so many ignorant people in this world. Asia should have won because if you listened to robin at the end, she wanted the person who has grown the most and could handle all aspects and still perform. Well in case you forgot who was the one who won the commercial because she knew how to talk, shoot a commercial on the first try where the other 2 girls had about 10-20 takes. So if I wanted to choose a winner I would choose someone who can speak correctly without the producers giving me cue cards or have to sing it just to make a commercial . Where I did like Chelsea face it she can”t dance on the same level and Mellisa was fake has vampire teeth like the judge said “A deer in headlights. Now she can go to medical school and try to cure the “asiahaternisis” Go Asia ignore these ignorant people I”m very proud of you!

April 25, 2007 at 7:03 pm
(72) Kassenia says:

I really see how sad a lot of people are. So, what the person you wanted did not win. If your eyes was open and you watched the performance, as I did,Asia was the mature individual. She had one break down while going through PMS…she attempted to help Chelsea when Melissa didn’t. I feel they all have unique talent, but Asia, rocked the house. I really wish our society would learn how to support and love each person as a given and stop throwing out so much hate!

Peace out…and freedom of speech doesnot mean belittering another person.

April 25, 2007 at 7:13 pm
(73) rita says:

I’m VERY excited that she won… SHE needed to. She looked better than the other girls, she is more mature and she can perform. Ya’ll just HATERS because ya’ll can’t be like my girl Asia! SHE is every woman… a mother, a leader, a powerful, don’t put up with no mess woman, and everything else in between WOMAN.

April 25, 2007 at 7:30 pm
(74) ryan says:

I like all three contestants. It take a lot of courage to stand on a stage and perform. I could not do it. Everything else is not important and getting caught in it is ridiculous. I congratulate any of the girls who participated in the journey and who took risks big and small. Good luck to all of them!

April 25, 2007 at 7:34 pm
(75) Rii says:

UGH!
Chelsea or Melissa should have won!!! its not fair! I mean, yeah, Asias ok but Melissa and CHelsea are way better!@!! Do be honest, I dont think Asias vocals were strong enough. COme on, someone can be taught how to dance, but a voice like Asias is sometimes not possible to repair. WHY TAKE THE CHANCE!!!!!!! I wish CHelsea would have won! She and Melissa actually look like Dolls. And the fight that Melissa and Asia had doesnt proove taht Asias mature. it gives Melissa the same label, but sometimes u have to be like that!!!!!!

April 25, 2007 at 7:36 pm
(76) Law & Order says:

STOP THE HATE HATERS!
Jenna,Monkeyville and Renne… STOP IT!
why should Asia answer to you about anything? who are you? Oops! let me guess…YOU ARE THOSE WHO MISSED YOUR 15 MNS FAME ON “GIRLS GONE WILD.” You are not as innocent as you want to believe, so don’t judge ASIA. She does not owe you ZITCH. Call your mommy and ask her first about the skeletons in her closet before you can demand a pick into Asia’s closet. And that is YOUR responsibility. :)

BREATHE!

April 25, 2007 at 7:45 pm
(77) jhb says:

Congratulations Asia! I think she is going to be a great addition to the group. All the girls were good/talented, but the judges picked the one who would compliment the group!

April 25, 2007 at 7:49 pm
(78) Kiku says:

WELL SAID jhb!

April 25, 2007 at 8:11 pm
(79) Man says:

Boooooooo…. another drama queen, that thinks the world owes her something just cause she got knocked up

April 25, 2007 at 8:24 pm
(80) Nikki Griffin says:

My kids and I are very excited for Asia. She is well deserved. She is a great role model for her daughter, except for the “f” word. But Melissa deserved it. Asia prevailed. You go girl!

April 25, 2007 at 8:38 pm
(81) Tabi says:

OMG i cant belive that asia won!!! i mean she is pretty/talented and all that but then her vocals, ill give that a thumbs down. i thought that melissa was going to win because when she was performing, i thought that she really did look lik nicole. and did you see ron fair twitched his head when asia was saying finga instead of finger. she is good and all that but then i thought that melissa was better than her

April 25, 2007 at 9:21 pm
(82) Thonja says:

I AM SO HAPPY ASIA WON SHE IS BEAUTIFUL AND HAS SPUNK

April 25, 2007 at 10:14 pm
(83) Gail says:

Congratulations to Asia, they were all very good, but she was by far the best.
Gail

April 25, 2007 at 10:27 pm
(84) Kelly says:

I enjoyed all three performances.It’s really nice to see such young women with such strong talents. Melissa and Chelsea, I hope to see you girls really soon and if not just remember to keep your heads up and do something positive with your lives. U rock. Asia, congratulations. I wish u the best and I loved watching you grow.

April 25, 2007 at 10:52 pm
(85) Britt-Britt says:

Asia won it fair and square…..So yall need to go hate on somebody else…She showed them that she could be something so yall need to go do something wit yall life and leave Asia alone..Yeah Chelsea and Melissa waz good but Aisa waz GREAT…

April 25, 2007 at 10:54 pm
(86) Kelli says:

Chelsea sooo should have won…she really could have brought something original to the group!

April 25, 2007 at 11:04 pm
(87) Josie says:

Asia deserved to win. If you look at the current Dolls and their creator, Robin, the “trashy” motif is fitting. Chelsea just did not fit in, with the image. Asia and Melissa, exhibited the trashy “edge,” that Chelsea could not, no matter how she evolved, week, over week. If Ron Fair is as good as he thinks he is, he will market Chelsea’s talents in a more sophisticated direction, where she belongs. The ironic thing with this competition is that it blows the doors off the sophmoric American (so-called) Idol. Any one of the PSD contestants, were better performers, than those wannabes on Idol.

April 25, 2007 at 11:53 pm
(88) Lissie says:

I don’t think she fit in the PCD. She should have just take care & raise of her daughter. Now, she will never raise her properly bec she’ll be busy. Melissa R is the perfect PCD. I think they are racist bec Melissa is asian. oh well! sucks!

April 26, 2007 at 9:19 am
(89) Missy says:

Can Asia sing without tapping her fingers on the microphone so much?? and when she screams and screaches she opens her mouth too wide. I think she is like a little sewer rat. And with her love of “street fighting” she acts like one too!! And the PCD’s are so well spoken. Asia will hopefully not have to speak publicly for awhile!!!

April 26, 2007 at 9:23 am
(90) Krissy says:

Yeah….Asia does do that microphone thing ALOT. Really annoying. And all of the PCD’s are so pretty. I think she looks more like a 12 year old boy then a woman. I think Melissa R was the Ideal Doll. Chelsea is very talented but really has a future with her singing career and should not worry. And Asia is a mother. how can she say she is doing this for her daughter? SHE WILL NEVER SEE HER!! Grandma will raise her and Asia will just pay for expensive schooling, clothes,etc. Maybe get her living in a nice town. But a girl needs her Mother. There is no replacement for that

April 26, 2007 at 9:26 am
(91) Chayteevia Robinson says:

I loved Asia’s Performance and my friends and I felt like she was the best fit for the group. Shout-Outs to Asia and the Group. GOOD LUCK!!!

April 26, 2007 at 9:29 am
(92) meeyaumi says:

Can anyone give me the information on the song that Melissa sang last night. It was sooooo beautiful, and she did such a wonderful job.

Thanks,

April 26, 2007 at 9:30 am
(93) girly girl says:

YES I agree with “miss” way up top. you hit the nail on the head! Why does Asia look like she is in pain when she sings???? and she screams and forces the words out!!! REALLY ANNOYING. But, like some others said, she was the trashiest so she had to win. And you all going on and on about Melissa R. Not winning because she is asian???? Seriously. She is Filipino!!! Since when is there racism asgaist Filipinos???? I am from Hawaii and they are some of the prettiest girls you will see!! The racism thing is all in your heads people. really.

April 26, 2007 at 10:24 am
(94) leeroy says:

i think they should had both chelsea and melissa win. i would like to see them with a few others that were booted off the show start their own group

April 26, 2007 at 10:42 am
(95) leeroy says:

chelsea stood out to me the whole show. i think if she were in the mix of the PCDs it would take too much attention off her and she’s the one i would want to see. and i think a group like that would take some of her own style away. i would have like to see her win but i know she has potential to make it big herself.

April 26, 2007 at 10:59 am
(96) Monica says:

I am glad Asia won. Her vocals may not have been as strong as Chelsea and Melissa’s but her singing was not bad. She is beautiful inside and out, a great dancer, sexy and most of all a teamplayer. You can’t be catty working with a bunch of women. She will be a great role model, eventhough she is a young and single mother, she showed that you can still pursue your dreams. Asia you go girl!!

April 26, 2007 at 11:11 am
(97) Kelly says:

chelsea should have won : (

April 26, 2007 at 11:11 am
(98) pineapple says:

OMG. I cant believe some of the ignorant comments I have just read. Let’s face it the only person who really needed to have a say so in who became the next doll was the creator Robin. Asia won and that is the best choice. I really likde Melissa R. up until the last episode. For her to bad talk Melissa S. as soon as she left was phony like Asia called it. Then for Melissa to bring Asia’s daughter into it was when she really lost my vote. Now she can just go on and be the doctors her parents want her to be. I wish Chelsea all the best- that girl can blow. Congratualations Asia and you have to fight real hard now to balance this 24 hour lifestyle. Don’t give up because you have a lot of haters as you can see. I wish you all the best.

April 26, 2007 at 11:31 am
(99) lisa says:

All I hav eto say on here to everybody is STOP HATIN!!!!!!!!!!!!!

April 26, 2007 at 11:44 am
(100) di says:

Congrats Asia. You are a beautiful young woman, inside and out. One day you will realized that. Don’t let rude comments and haters get to you. All of the finalists had decent talent, but Chelsea, Mariella and Asia stuck out for being “exceptional”. Neither of the Melissa’s danced, sang or looked as good as they thought they did.
ASIA – STAY STRONG!

April 26, 2007 at 12:11 pm
(101) readeebear says:

I am disappointed that Asia won. She is nice-looking , and a good dancer, but her attitude is very “funky” and unprofessional. I have no problem with someone defending themselves, or having confidence, but Asia has to much “divatude” , for her to be just starting out. Also, that fingerfluttering on the microphone is annoying, plus her facial expressions remind me of Grace Jones in one of her movies. She looks like she is going to fight tigers and bears or something. She would be good on the wrestling circuit. My vote was for Chelsea, she is just plain cute, and she could sing. She could improve on dancing as time with one. Melissa was my next choice because she could sing and dance, and she was beautiful, but I wondered like some of you, if they didn’t pick her because she resembles Nicole, and of course they wouldn’t want any one upstaging her.

April 26, 2007 at 1:29 pm
(102) shaylin says:

She shouldnt have won…even though Chelsea couldnt dance all that well she was still better…she never gave up and that was what should have let her win…and Asia couldnt sing…well she could but she wanted to sound too much like the other singers.

April 26, 2007 at 1:30 pm
(103) diedre says:

Asia was the best and thats that.The other girls were so boring and unoriginal.I feel so much hatred from all the comments towards asia.Why so much hatred.ummmmmm………

April 26, 2007 at 1:45 pm
(104) jon says:

Asia Was the wrong choice. They could of picked one of those singers on Hollywood Blvd. That would of been a lot more interesting!!! Asia will be out by the end of the year…

April 26, 2007 at 1:51 pm
(105) Mike says:

OMG!!!! I will never understand these stupid reality shows??? Asia was the wrong choice for the PCD!! But, who really cares!!! That Nicole girl is the whole package for the PCD. Nicole is the only one who sings, so Asia will be just another backup dancer. She will just hummmmm like the rest of the girls and get paid well to do it!!!..LOL And by the way I thought that the Melisa girl should of won.. but I think she looked way to much like Nicole and they couldn’t have that!!!!

April 26, 2007 at 2:17 pm
(106) Helena says:

Very disappointing. Asia is a nice,hardworking girl, and she really needed to win and is talented, but the truth is that what happened between her and Melissa R. the night before finale was crucial. I think Melissa R. should have just ignore whatever comment Asia made and not get into arguing or asking her all the crap she did. Melissa was going to be the winner, but she was not wise. I was voting for Chelsea beautiful, great singer, and yes, not a great dancer, but a quick learner. She was going to take away a lot from the lead singer, that is why she did not win. Nobody is born dancing…Bad choice…

April 26, 2007 at 2:31 pm
(107) anonymous says:

MELISSA R SUCKS. VICIOUS BITCH. I HATE THAT BITCH. IF SHE WON I WOULD JUST DIE. THANK GOD ASIA WON. CHELSEA U WERE GREAT ALSO.

April 26, 2007 at 2:34 pm
(108) NATALI says:

YAY SHE WON I LOVED HER FROM THE BEGINING AND I HOPE SHE HAS A GOOD LIFE WITH HER BABY SHE IS A GREAT MOTHER AND DISERVES THE BEST YOU WILL BE GREAT NO MATTER WHAT

April 26, 2007 at 3:03 pm
(109) kayla says:

Omg evry one thinks Melisa.r. should of one but i think not she’s a fake bitch god i hate her that horey ass bitch lol holla at me if you het or not at gangstakayla1234@hotmail.com

April 26, 2007 at 3:03 pm
(110) sandra says:

melisa r sucks i like chelse and asia but asia deserved to win robin started crying when she called chelase’s name well you rock asia :]

April 26, 2007 at 3:06 pm
(111) krysi says:

Asia is a great performer.She wowed the crowd with her performance at the finale.She is all about stardom in every sense of the word. She is a hustler,fighter,(and at that age!)I have my reservations about her but I was with her from the get.I liked the others to, but there is only one winner-Asia.

April 26, 2007 at 5:23 pm
(112) sarah says:

asia u r so beautiful!!!!!!!!!!!!! i am your #1fan.i watch u everyday on tv!!!!I LOVE U ASIA!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

April 26, 2007 at 5:23 pm
(113) Monica Again says:

Their is too much hating towards Asia. Yes the other girls were good, thats why they were finalist and Asia was better thats why she won. Why do she need to stay home and be a mother to her daughter – what kind of comment is that. Just like any other celebrity with children, she could still be a good parent to her child and a better provider. As far as the argument, Melissa had to say something to Asia regarding the comment Asia made about her being fake because the truth hurts and guilt. She know she is a fake and Asia was just keeping it real. I liked Chelsea and I like Melissa but they just didn’t have what it takes POINT BLANK. LIKE i SAID ASIA IS A TEAMPLAYER, SHE WAS NICE ENOUGH TO HELP CHELSEA WITH HER DANCING WHEN NO ONE ELSE WOULD AND SHE IS VERY ENTERTAINING. Asia I wish you all the best.

April 26, 2007 at 6:45 pm
(114) Tiffany says:

I dont see why everyone is making such a huge deal on Asia winning. All 3 of them deserved it. My overall vote was on Chelsea but I didnt care who won, becuase no matter whos up there doing it, all 3 of them would have done an amazing job. I love Chelsea man can that girl sing, and I dont see how people say shes a bad dancer. Just because she has more respect for the look she gives off to other people, they think she cant dance. Asia’s an awesome dancer and she can sing, and Melissa R can dance and sing as well. Either 3 of them Deserved to be there. All 3 of them are Drop dead gorgeous, and whoever won i was extremely happy for. I cried when Chelsea got voted off and I cried when Asia won. Way to Go Asia!! Chelsea you will do great things with your life with your singing and dancing, and sell records that will go way to the top. Asia so will you, and Melissa R will do the same.

April 26, 2007 at 6:50 pm
(115) jenn says:

Why is asia not a good role model cuz she has a baby that ridiculous …

April 26, 2007 at 6:52 pm
(116) Jimba says:

I know im kinda late…but to kenny J. It seems like your saying that people are being racist because asia is a woman of color. If you mean color as black…then your wrong because Asia isnt black. Shes Hispanic. Im not trying to get crazy with you but its just i went 2 school with her and i kno. So just to set the record straight ASIA is not black! lol but congrats 2 her she was always a star.

April 26, 2007 at 7:07 pm
(117) some one says:

wow your comments are funny 2 read… i luv chelsea and asia SUCKS she will never beable 2 take car of he kidd!!!

April 26, 2007 at 7:35 pm
(118) Maria says:

i really like melissa r, i she was my FIRST favourite since the beginning of the show. i dont really think she’s fake but people do make mistakes and i guess what she said to asia was abad thing. i mean not all of us are perfect. but i dont really care if asia won. all i know is that she’s going far than asia. i thought asia was watever but congrats though.i mean i get the point that she is doing this for her child but like what i said, whatever. i mean i get the point that the PCD was only looking for back up dancing and singer. melissa r can go WAY farther and she is better to be a soloist

MELISSA R. U ARE MY ROLE MODEL!!

April 26, 2007 at 7:41 pm
(119) Catalina says:

i so wanted melissa R. to win because she the best out of all of the 3 and aisa has a kid at home how is she going to take care of her kid when she ding her carrer or her jog and her baby going to tell her why don’t u ever spent some time with me!!! u suck aisa

April 26, 2007 at 8:27 pm
(120) Tina says:

Are you people crazy Asia is the person that should have won. Yall are just some haters and if u watched every show like I did you would know that I love you Asia and I wish you the best of luck on everything. And it is nothing wrong with her having a baby so yall nedd to shut up. She is perfect and prettier than all the other girls so face it those other sluts didn’t deserve to win.

April 26, 2007 at 9:58 pm
(121) Jade says:

Asia was the most passionate and had the most drive.

April 26, 2007 at 10:49 pm
(122) Den says:

Asia should of NEVER won. She hates girls. This group will be sorry they added her to the group. She said she is proud to be an 18 year old single mom. Yeah like you got pregnant on purpose. BTW Asia it is pronounced asked not axed. Chelsea should of won period.

April 27, 2007 at 1:16 am
(123) anonymous says:

Jimba, you went to school with Asia? Great. I do understand Kenny to a point. It’s obvious that she is not full-blooded black, but she is still a person of color. To educate yourself, there are many types of Hispanics, esp. around the New York/New England area. There are Cuban-blacks, Puerto Ricans(black-indian-etc.), you name it! Most Hispanics do have mixed ancestry. But that is not the point.That would be a whole day National Geographic story…
Some of us just feel that she is being targeted because she does not represent the “All American” dream, if you know what I mean?
I truly wish her the best, even against adversity………

April 27, 2007 at 2:37 pm
(124) Suse says:

holy cow, what were they thinking. I thought Melissa had this one in the bag.
Chealsea we like you, but you are young and i am sure that you will do well down the road. Asia, I don’t think that you will last long – too much drama there!!!

April 27, 2007 at 2:48 pm
(125) Akira says:

I been with Asia from the begining i know she was going to win her baby girl is so pretty and so is her the doll are complet so go Asia this was all ur u had it u won it

April 27, 2007 at 3:50 pm
(126) jo says:

CONGRATULATIONS Asia!! I’m glad you won. You’ve won in more ways than one. I was torn between Chelsea and Asia. You put a lot on the line when you helped Chelsea with the dance (that in itself showed character). I watched Melissa R. purposely try to pick a fight with Asia. Some would have been disqualified for smacking some sense into that spoiled brat. Asia defended herself. ALWAYS stand up for yourself, Asia. This should prove to Melissa that she can’t have everything she wants. So you have a baby, another person to love. The only difference between you and most American girls and sex is that you have living proof. Most women are working moms nowdays. It usually takes at least 2 incomes to live decently in America, there are very few stay-at-home moms. So you’re not doing 9-5 in an office or serving fast-food out of a window or another traditional job, but you are making the most of being a beautiful, talented, strong, and courageous person. Keep up the good work and encourage other young people to use their gifts and talents to follow their dreams. To the people who have a problem with the color…GET OVER IT!!! WE’RE HERE TO STAY!!!

April 27, 2007 at 6:41 pm
(127) Laura says:

I think the right women won the show and for all of you that dont think so can kiss her a** because she is beautiful,talented,and a strong mother who can dance her heart out so just get over yourselfs.HA HA! Bitch

April 27, 2007 at 6:57 pm
(128) megan says:

OK Asia sucked butt at singing and she looks like a fricken man when she dances! I would have wanted anybody else to win EXCEPT HER she sucks so go home and feed your baby ASIA!!!

April 28, 2007 at 12:34 am
(129) Trish says:

Asia is 1/4 Filipino, Melissa is Filipino, and Nicole Sherzinger is part Filipino. Damn, Filipinos rock!

April 28, 2007 at 1:39 am
(130) pamila says:

I think the PCD chose the right girl, Asia outshine Chelsea and Melissa R., Melissa R. chose to sing her song just like Nicole, and besides that Asia could dance. How many can say that Asia acted out first, I don’t think you seen the same show as I did. AS I recall Melissa r. deliberately tried to get Asia upset, b/c she knew how to push her buttons, she cussed first, and then told her what to do about her child that was not her business to comment on her child. As far as her sacrificing her child, she did the right thing by trying to make something out of her life and trying to make sure she doesn’t have to struggle it is hard for a single mother to raise a child.
also no one commented on her trying to help Chelsea dance, she didn’t have to do that. I didn’t see her peeps trying to help. come on now, you should be fair and stop hating, if you thought you could have done better you should of tryed out instead of being negative, asia is a very beautiful girl, and your comments prove on about what she had to go through during her childhood, people hating on others.

April 28, 2007 at 4:42 pm
(131) christelle says:

i am so happy she won so back off hayers

April 28, 2007 at 5:24 pm
(132) Carmen says:

Asia was the whole package! For those who think she is not a good role model because she had a child they need to back off. She is making something of herself. I was a single mom @ 20 and 17 years later I am working a fortune 500 co. Asia…YOU GO GIRL!

April 28, 2007 at 7:47 pm
(133) Deondre says:

I LOVE ASIA. IM GLAD SHE WON.A SINGLE MOTHER,AND TALENTED.SHE DONT NEED A MAN 2 MAKE IT HAPPEN SHE CAN DO IT BY HERSELF

I LOVE U ASIA

April 29, 2007 at 10:13 pm
(134) Walter says:

Well okay so I was rooting for Chelsea because I liked her better BUT the better girl won! Asia is an uniquely beautiful singer/DANCER that will stand out in the group but will not overshadow the lead vocalist. Melissa had the perfect everything but she was boring! Chelsea had the voice but it really matters that she can’t dance. Good luck Asia. You deserved to win.

April 29, 2007 at 10:33 pm
(135) Asiafan says:

Please stop the hating. Alot of people use this lame excuse that Asia was a “diva” or that she had a bad attitude. If its atitudees your judging this contest by, Did you guys what to see Sisily, Melissa s., and melissa r’s attitude (which really came out at the end).All three of them attitudes sucks and they were the real “Divas”.You dont have to be black woman to be labeled the “Diva”. Asia worked hard for this.stop hatin, She deserves to be in a competion like anyone else. She won.GET OVERR IT, now.

April 29, 2007 at 11:18 pm
(136) Sher1 says:

Everyone has attitude. It’s not only Melissa S. and Melissa R. Of course it’s getting close to the finale, it’s every woman for them selves. Who wouldn’t have attitude problems. Anyways, stop getting mad, they picked Asia, so let it be. I would prefer if they picked Melissa R. or Chelsea, but being on tv will open up opportunities and doors for Melissa and Chelsea. Good luck girls, we hope to see you guys soon!

April 30, 2007 at 2:34 pm
(137) nina says:

I can tell a lot of the hating comments made are from some very young immature people. Coming from a single mom working full time and in school part time, you have to make sacrafices for your children. You strecth yourself thin! Asia is young and so is her daughter, now is the best time. By the time her daughter is able to long for and miss mom she’ll be well established and more able to juggle the life. From the beginning of the show she had a goal and worked her butt off to achieve it. She did it and I couldn’t be more happy for her as a person. Yes, her father is half black/half philipino, making her no matter what Black. Does that make a difference to you all leaving negative comments i don’t know, but give her credit she was the only one who was consistent in her performance. The girl is a natural and has a raw talent that can and will be developed. At some point we all have some growing up to do. Hell, she’s 18. How many 18 yr olds out there step up to the plate to make the choices and sacrafices she has this far?

April 30, 2007 at 8:07 pm
(138) Monica says:

Asia obviously won because of her ethnicity. Melissa was the best of the three, with Chelsea a close second. Correct me if I am wrong, but I believe PCD is a “group” and with Asia’s attitude problem and numerous displays of not being a team player, how is this a good choice? I believe this one to be ‘chosen’ a looong way back to have a ‘politically correct’ group. Sadly, many individuals, (myself included) stated they will no longer watch this show because it is not ‘true’ reality and the best person did not win. I actually really loved the show, until Asia won…. Good Luck PCD–you are going to need it!!!

April 30, 2007 at 11:00 pm
(139) anonymous says:

Get a life Monica! Something tells me that you haven’t accomplished that much in life yourself…
What’s the problem, are u the wrong ethnicity?
Please, there are plenty of ways for the PCD’s to be politically correct. Besides, the group seems to portray an exotic,alluring, cross-cultural, seductive image anyway. Asia will fit right in, including her unique talents……….
Haters usually have to bring others down to justify their own shortcomings.

April 30, 2007 at 11:54 pm
(140) leeroy says:

chelsea and mel got the shaft when robin gave them some slow, boring songs to preform to, and gave asia one she could be-bop to. i hope asia enjoyed the spotlight while it lasted cuz she won’t be in it much with the PCDs

May 1, 2007 at 12:18 am
(141) samantha says:

i dont like Asia.. i want chelsea to win. even though chelsea is not good in dancing.. she has the potential 2 win!..

May 1, 2007 at 12:56 am
(142) ASHLEY says:

OH MY GOD!!!! I CANT BELIVE ASIA WON!!! I REALLY WANTED MELISSA R TO WIN :(

May 1, 2007 at 10:09 am
(143) Kris says:

Asia “won because of her ethnicity?” that was the lamest comment MONICA. What the heck does that have to do with anything. Clearly everyone would not have agreed on any decision, and regardless the true judges based their decision on overall talent. It has nothing to do with anyone have a child. That’s no ones business, we’re always so quick to judge another. There are many women in this industry that we see everyday that have children so what makes Asia that much different?
In my opinion a lot of the girls have a lot of growing up to do, and maybe this industry is what they need to make that happen.
Congrats to the winner and good luck to all of the women, everyone has a lot of talent and they all will do well no matter what!

May 1, 2007 at 8:24 pm
(144) annon. says:

Nina: who says the other girls didn’t work their butts off either, and just because Asia has to make different sacrifices and choices (because of a mistake she made herself earlier on in getting pregnant) doesn’t give her special status.
cynthia: just because Asia needed it, doesn’t mean she should get it. We all need things does that mean we all get it? NO. Oh well I guess they needed a back up to just blend in behind nicole and not overpower nicole.

May 4, 2007 at 5:37 pm
(145) quinn says:

EVERYONE THE JUDGES DIDNT THINK ASIA WAS GOOD ENOUGH SO SHE DOESNOT GET TO PERFORME WITH THEM

MELISSA REYES DOES NOT WIN!!!!!!!!!!!!

THEY ARE SHOWING A NEW SEASION WITH ALL NEW GIRLS BECAUSE THEY ALL WERE NOT GOOD ENOUGH!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

May 11, 2007 at 9:23 pm
(146) rEEVAH says:

cHELsea is unique and she doesnt look like any other dolls and she is so hott broo asia can go jump off a cliff!!!
peacee^^

May 17, 2007 at 3:25 pm
(147) MEKIA MIAMI says:

***HATERS DON’T GET NO PLAY******* ONCE AGAIN I’M BACK I WOULD TELL EVERYONE ON HERE DISSING ASIA ABOUT THEM SELFS BUT AS I CAN SEE ITS TWO MANY HATERS. GO FISHING OR WHATEVER YOU LIKE TO DO BEST AND GET UP OFF THE WINNER ASIA.
H$A$T$E$R$S
GO FIND SOMETHING TO DO…………

May 17, 2007 at 3:46 pm
(148) MEKA MIAMI says:

IF YOU ARE A MAN ON HERE DISSING ASIA YOU SHOULD BE ASHAME OF YOURSELF GO S**K SOME COCK AND IF YOU ARE A WOMEN ON HERE WELL ITS EXPECTED OF COURSE YOU B**CHES JUST JEALOUS.LOL… SHE WAS THE WINNER FROM THE START. SO FALL BACK HATERS. I BET SHE LOOK AND DANCE AND SING BETTER THEN Y’ALL A**.

May 23, 2007 at 1:25 am
(149) leeroy says:

MEKA MIAMI is obviously an uneducated bimbo off the block. my guess is she hadn’t even seen the show until the last episode. and i wouldn’t be suprised if she’s a 19 year old with 3 kids who spends her time mooching off the goverment while watching re-runs of the maury show all day.

May 23, 2007 at 12:39 pm
(150) apple says:

I REALLY THOUGHT MELISSA REYES WILL WIN THAT CONTEST! *SIGH*

May 31, 2007 at 4:28 pm
(151) MEKAMIAMI says:

LEEROY YOU MUST BE GAY WHAT TYPE OF DUDE WILL BE ON THIS SITE CHATING AND HATING.WHAT SIZE HEELS YOU WEAR AND WHAT IS YOUR FAVORITE COLOR PINK OR PURPLE? OHH AND WHAT SIZE THONGS YOU WEAR. LEEROY STOP ACTING LIKE A B**CH GROW UP FAG!!! AND YEAH I’M GHETTO AND PRIDE OF IT AND GRADUATED FROM COLLEGE.DAMN LEEROY NOW YOU WANT TO HATE ON ME COME ON DUDE IF YOU ARE REALLY A DUDE.GO FIND SOMEBODY D**K SUCK!!!!!!!!!!!!!!1

June 3, 2007 at 11:31 pm
(152) leeroy says:

damn u wanna talk about hating meka? i’m kinda shocked more dudes dont watch this great show. what’s there not to like? how many guys get into american idols? quite a few i’d imagine. i knew i pretty much hit it on the screws you being down off da block. and graduating from college really doesn’t say much these days. with you being from the ghetto it’s no wonder why u would vote for a $5 hooker like asia. my guess is you’re cheaper than that! so unless u have anything intellegent to say, i would focus more on not collecting any STD’s this week.

June 8, 2007 at 3:31 pm
(153) mekamiami says:

Wussup leeroy yep its me again. The only thing u should be focusing on is not to catch an STD in your mouth.lol…. So leeroy where do you like it best in the a** or in the mouth, let me guess in the mouth thats why you can’t never shut the f**k up. Look fag find something to do go get a check up you can be a dead man walking!!!! Leeroy stop writing me ok. Have a nice life!!!!

June 10, 2007 at 1:42 pm
(154) teriyakiboy says:

lol you guys are so hilarious. Asia won and that’s over. But I really like Melissa R., she’s all packaged plus she’s Asian. However, Asia winning the competition was great. She’s also Asian.

June 13, 2007 at 1:19 am
(155) leeroy jenkins! says:

man i waited for a week or so to check out what you could come up with meka. the least you could have done there is come up with something more original to say. but i guess you only know a handful of actual english words, so i’ll give you an a for effort. now go have fun sticking frozen hot dogs up yourself. peace!

June 29, 2007 at 8:31 pm
(156) carolyn says:

asia girl you were the bomb diggity and when you and mellissa was argueing i wish you had slapped her in her face she is just jelous cause you are fierce you go girl keep yo head up cayse deserve to win you was the bomb!!!!

November 28, 2007 at 11:19 am
(157) Humairah says:

I just don’t like Asia wins it ever since the incident that she made Chelsea not being part of her team just because she doesn’t do good in dancing. She is selfish and not helping others! Sorry to say, I just don’t like she to be part of PCD. I think she is the lowest class among the others in PCD.

December 12, 2007 at 11:45 am
(158) Jamile says:

chelsea doenst know how to dance, asia doenst know how to sing. what about melissa?
she was perfect!
i still believe that chelsea should be the winner!

December 16, 2007 at 10:06 pm
(159) philip jarvis says:

i really want mellissa reyes to won…she has more capabilities than asia…asia so sucks…im crying when i saw melissa didn’t won…

December 31, 2007 at 3:54 am
(160) Melissa R fan says:

Im so dissapointed and sad because Melissa didnt wi !!! She deserved won !! She is the best !!! and Asia is ugly !!!

February 3, 2008 at 7:37 pm
(161) Renata says:

I’m also disappointed!!! First of all, I think Melissa S. should’ve be the winner. THis Asia girl, besides ugly (did you take a look at her theet?!), has a very forced and fake vocal, and has NOTHING of all the self control and the structure an artist needs. To be honest, I think the judges were trying to make the group look a bit more “racial”… If looking like a “poor little girl with a child” one is the secret to be sucessfull, then I’m gonna have a baby right now!!

February 16, 2008 at 9:04 am
(162) Paige says:

Has anyone seen Asia since she won? On the PCD site she isnt listed under ”the dolls”….? So idk whats going on.

February 24, 2008 at 7:03 pm
(163) carine says:

HI CHELSEY should win >>>>>> SHE THE BEST

March 8, 2008 at 9:49 pm
(164) Cutie Girl says:

Asia rocks! Y’all h8ers. Oh, and Melissa S. was a b****. Good job 2 Melissa R. and Chelsea as well!

I love S.P.

May 9, 2008 at 11:09 pm
(165) kelly says:

are you crazy??? i thing asia is the best, i love her voice , you can’t even sing like her, you are just jealeous!! i don’t give a …. what you think, i’m glad that asia won!!

Leave a Comment


Line and paragraph breaks are automatic. Some HTML allowed: <a href="" title="">, <b>, <i>, <strike>

©2014 About.com. All rights reserved.