1. Entertainment
Send to a Friend via Email

Your suggestion is on its way!

An email with a link to:


was emailed to:

Thanks for sharing About.com with others!

You can opt-out at any time. Please refer to our privacy policy for contact information.
Diane Anderson-Minshall

Why Was Angelea Disqualified on 'America's Next Top Model' All Stars?

By December 8, 2011

Follow me on:

Angelea Preston disqualified from America's Next Top Model All Stars

Read an update about why Angelea was disqualified.

The finale of America's Next Top Model All Stars included a shocking twist.

The three models still in the running to become America's next top model
(Angelea, Allison and Lisa) had photo shoots for a Cover Girl commercial and competed in a runway show that included an underwater modeling element.

But just when the judges were to begin their deliberations, it was announced that Angelea Preston had been disqualified from the competition and either Allison or Lisa would be crowned America's Next Top Model All Star.

So why was Angelea disqualified from the ANTM competition?

Other reality competitions have seen contenders disqualified for having an unreported conflict of interest or already being under contract.

But this season of America's Next Top Model featured a number of models who already have modeling contracts, so that seems unlikely.

According to the most prevalent rumors and whispering of insider gossips, the real reason Angelea was disqualified is because she revealed (on Facebook) who the final three models were before the results had aired.

In fact, it is obvious that the show did re-shoot the finale in Los Angeles, which (considering the cost, etc) it seems they would only do if they really had to. Like if they had to alter the results in some way.

Which leads me to believe the other rumor going around: That Angelea was originally chosen as the winner of America's Next Top Model All Stars, but lost the position after violating her confidentiality agreement. Then the other two finalists re-shot the finale with Lisa D'Amato taking home the title. Read more about the finale.

CW released this official statement:

"After production wrapped on the current cycle of America's Next Top Model, we learned information that made Angelea ineligible and she was subsequently disqualified from the competition.  As a result, new scenes were filmed to address this for the audience during the finale."

What do you think? Should Angelea have been disqualified? Was it fair? Does it make Lisa's win seem less authentic? Comment below or take the poll on the Reality TV Forum.

Photo © CW


December 8, 2011 at 3:11 am
(1) A. Pittman says:

Angelea won, therefore they should have given her the title. She didn’t lie about anything. I’m praying for Angelea to get even another chance.

Lisa won by default. She is not the real winner.

December 8, 2011 at 3:13 am
(2) Angel says:

Angelea should not have been disqualified. She didn’t lie about anything. She made a mistake.

Lisa won by default. She is not the real winner.

December 8, 2011 at 3:49 am
(3) A Fan says:

If Angelie was the winner,then she should be considered the winner-considering the controversy with Saliesha winning cycle 9 under even worse accusations what she did should not even matter-it’s not like she revealed who won the whole thing!!!!!

December 8, 2011 at 3:58 am
(4) Amber says:

Angelea really should never have won or gotten in the top 3 to begin with! She is an emotional train wreck which is not what you want to promoting as a role model. To reward her for her emotional breakdown AGAIN on the Modeland set was dreadful! Lisa or Allison deserved it more anyhow.

December 8, 2011 at 4:32 am
(5) JOjo says:

Anglea should not have been a Winner by anyone other than Andre’s standards. She whined about everything and modeling seems to be as cut throat as it can be right now. She would have never survived, much less portrayed the Top Model persona.
Good job Lisa, but still think Laura should have won.

December 8, 2011 at 4:55 am
(6) Lisa w says:

Angelee was a model , however in my opinion, only made the top three to keep the show interesting from a “Chaos’ point of view..Dominque would have been my third person..SHE is beautiful.. but understanding how those who perservere win ANTM..Lisa was the obvious choice. ROLE MODEL for the masses..pictures really come second…

December 8, 2011 at 5:34 am
(7) juliejohnson says:

I think Laura should have won the whole thing… to me she had the looks, she was a role model that I would like my 19 year old to look up too and most of all she had the attitude a role mode should have… She wasn’t like Lisa and Angelea to me back stabbing, conniving and didn’t care about anyone but themselves.. and poor Allison, I liked her but if you can’t keep your eyes open for a shoot you don’t need to be shot.. she would make a good actress for the Twilight movies… lol

December 8, 2011 at 5:54 am
(8) Rosette says:

I was backing Angelea 100% and despite the breakdowns the girl is beautiful and talented. I hope this rumor is not true but if so Angelea has learned a very valuable lesson.

Love you Angelea, keep up the modeling, singining or corresponding, you have it all.

December 8, 2011 at 6:56 am
(9) Kai says:

Honestly Angelea wasn’t that great to begin with and if you’re going to be stupid enough to tell everyone you won then you should be disqualified on account of being an idiot.

And I don’t know why everyone says she won by default. That would only work if there was only two. It’s not like they have a bottom two to decide who was runner up. They had to rejudge without Angelea in the picture and Allison and Lisa didn’t know which would win.

I do feel bad for my poor Allison though. Having her dreams crushed as runner up three times in a row….that’s just heartless.

December 8, 2011 at 7:26 am
(10) Midge says:

I think if Angelea did in fact win she should not have been disqualified. Maybe reprimanded. Lisa knowing that she won by default lets her know who the better of the three was, Angelea. Most real women get emotional but they get over that when situations get better. Wow, doesn’t everyone make mistakes sometime. Don’t hate on Angelea because she is a little rough around the edges. Most people lack the proper social graces, that can be taught.

December 8, 2011 at 7:30 am
(11) Sally says:

Lisa was the total package. She worked hard and deserved the win.

December 8, 2011 at 7:39 am
(12) Cynthia says:

Angelea should never have been in the top 3. She never won a challenge until the last, has a flacid body
and has the character of an alley cat! I give her points for perservence and drive but that’s not enough to be ANTM.

December 8, 2011 at 7:59 am
(13) Mark says:

Angelea was too ghetto to be the winner. She was not classy enough to be America’s next top model (not that Lisa is much better). I don’t really agree with any of the top 3 as contenders – Dominique and Laura should have been there!

December 8, 2011 at 8:24 am
(14) ERB says:

Why do people not understand what a contract is. If you sign a contract with certain terms spelled out, then break the contract by defying the terms, the contract is voided. It has nothing to do with feelings or I changed my mind. It is a legal document. This great country was built under the foundation of legal contract and law. Stability is lost when people entering into a contract can’t trust that the contract will be honored. Jeez. So if she signed a contract, then broke the terms of the contract, she is disqualified. Her feelings don’t matter.

December 8, 2011 at 9:07 am
(15) Ashanti says:

i think that if angelea actually won then she should have kept her big mouth shut about it. I dont really think any of the three that they had left were really qualified to win. Angelea is not refined enough to be in anybody’s italian vogue magazine. Allison was a big-eyed weirdo who hid behind her hair every episode. Lisa is a freak of nature who can’t be tamed. I think these people should have went home first. I do agree that Laura should have at last been in the top three though. Tyra, you can do better than this. this season is a desperate attempt to keep the top model show going………and it is dead! It died about 6 cycles ago! Lets move on people.

December 8, 2011 at 9:25 am
(16) Jennifer says:

Angelea Preston is American’s Next Top Model All Star….
I pray that this does not affect her career..

December 8, 2011 at 9:29 am
(17) jigsaw8215 says:

I was going for Angelea 100%. I did think that she needed some refining but, with the opportunity that would have come. If she indeed broke the contract then she should have been disqualified. I hate it though because she has been given so many chances with ATM that she should have known better.

December 8, 2011 at 9:31 am
(18) sheila says:

Let’s be honest she was on the show before and knows about the confidentiality agreements she isnt new to this so she should have never said anything about it. Her inability to hold it together just proves she wasn’t ready to be a Extra host or write on a blog. And especially if she won that’s even worse that she would be that careless

December 8, 2011 at 9:32 am
(19) Barb says:

Angelea got ripped off. She is stunning, and Lisa is a dog.

December 8, 2011 at 9:36 am
(20) BAPS says:

If Angelea won, she should’ve been congratulated. She did not lie, she just posted who the final 3 were. I have been a model for 35yrs, and the modeling industry is very cut throat. Considering where Angelea came from I think she is a wonderful role model for other under-priviledged girls. For all of you that are calling her ghetto and an emotional wreck look around at your own life before you start throwing stones at someone else. The girl is human, and we as humans make mistakes. She shouldn’t been disqualified, and for Tyra to sit back and let that happen to her is awful, so awful that I have started a petition to boycott the show next season. Lisa on the other hand is an alcoholic and drug addict, so she will make a wonderful role model right? She won by default and Angelea is still the WINNER in my eyes and she will get picked up by a top modeling agency. ANGELEA HOLD YOUR HEAD UP AND CONTINUE TO PURSUE YOUR DREAMS.

December 8, 2011 at 9:49 am
(21) ga_peach says:

What everyone seems to be overlooking is that she signed a legally binding contract and a confidentiality agreement. She violated that contract and has to accept the consequences of that which is disqualification.

December 8, 2011 at 10:01 am
(22) KS says:

If she broke the agreement, they were right to disqualify her. I think Laura should have won the entire thing.

December 8, 2011 at 10:09 am
(23) cleo says:

I personally don’t like or care.for angelea. I’m sorry but there are other contestant who had a sob story and has had worse she just used it as an excuse to get some more love to her. On another note as one comment before it wouldn’t matter if Lisa won by default or not she signed an agreement and hello people she violated it. Besides I don’t believe that she was.going to be ghe winner anyways her pictures aren’t as good as Lisa’s. So yep if she lost there’s no sympathy for her and she shouldn’t complain about anything she should go back and read what she signed, she F’d up her career on her own and she has no one to blame but herself.

December 8, 2011 at 10:16 am
(24) Maggie S. says:

The only thing that makes sense is that Angelea won because otherwise there would be no reason to re-shoot the finale. On the show, Nigel said that the producers learned something from (not about) Angelea which disqualified her.

If she did leak who won, why would she wait 2 weeks before the finale to reveal it knowing she would be disqualified? She may be a little rough around the edges but she isn’t an idiot. That facebook account isn’t even hers. All of this speculation means nothing because none of us knows the truth until the show tells us what REALLY happened.

December 8, 2011 at 10:37 am
(25) barb says:

its too bad, because i thiught Laura should have been the winner and i think they should have gone back and put her back in the finale. she was sweet and carried herself with dignaty. My husband actually watched with me last night and said that angelea should never had made it that far and thought laura should have been the winner. we both agree that lisa was the right choice though with what happened.

December 8, 2011 at 10:49 am
(26) Kw15 says:

Contract, contract, contract!!! I don’t care who would have one. I was rooting for any girl in the top 5. But look at it from this perspective. ANTM is first and foremost a business, and “how you feel” and saying “I’m sorry” just isn’t going to cut it. The terms are laid out from the outset. The show receives money per viewer, and if her leaking ANY pre-aired information caused even 1 person to not view the episode, then Angelea essentially swindled them of money that did not belong to her. And considering this was the last episode, the amount of people she “cheated” was probably larger. Remember what Tyra said in a previous season, “You do not mess with another girl’s money…”

December 8, 2011 at 10:51 am
(27) cwf says:

Angelea should have gone when they had Michael Jackson week! She’s a train wreck waiting to happen and plays on her background. See what always running your mouth gets you? Get some CLASS, Angelea! Although I think Lisa will do well if she learns to temper her enthusiasm when needed, I was really rooting for Laura. I actually cried when she was sent home! : ( She has got it all, and I was so disappointed to see her go. Anyway, I”m glad Angelea is NOT the next Top Model!

December 8, 2011 at 10:57 am
(28) chewy says:

Has anyone thought about this disqualification of Angelea being deliberate?…on Angelea’s part that is. Certainly the publicity surrounding her now and probably well into the future will keep her in the public eye far longer than Lisa or any other Top Model winner before her. Maybe Angelea is not so “idiotic” after all!

December 8, 2011 at 11:03 am
(29) 1009 says:

Poor Buffalo. Always getting so close but always losing out to some boneheaded mistake. I was rooting for Angelea. The Buffalo streets aren’t that bad. There are definatley worse. But for some reason it’s more difficult to climb the greesy pole in B-Lo.
Viewers should have at least been given a reason and Angelea should have at least been given some props.

December 8, 2011 at 11:06 am
(30) me says:

I think the right person won (Lisa), a contract is a contract, be professional and do what your paid to do (Angelea)!

December 8, 2011 at 11:11 am
(31) Ms Sheila says:


December 8, 2011 at 11:12 am
(32) kathyob says:

I can’t believe that ANTM did not even try to explain to the audience why Angelea was disqualified. I was a loyal fan of the show and watched intently and anxiously awaiting the results. I feel cheated because we did not get all the information and we were basically forced to ignore the fact they only had two people in the finale not three. One commercial break and the whole damn show is ruined by their crappy alternate ending.

I am happy that Lisa won, though, because in my opinion, she should have won no matter what. She was the BEST candidate and deserved it. At least they eventually chose correctly, in my opinion.

December 8, 2011 at 11:20 am
(33) marlene says:

I don’t feel sorry for Anglea. Leeking info that was in contract is not right. And she knew it too. I also wanted Laura to win. The judges were crazy to criticize Laura for some sultry shots. A women is not just ONE thing. She was beautiful, sweet and sexy! I hope she has a wonderful career. Lisa is fine and I’m sure she’ll have a career.

December 8, 2011 at 11:20 am
(34) GB says:

Angelea is the winner regardless; she did the best in the finale and the judges voted for her PERIOD!

Those of you who say Lisa is a good role model; well wasn’t she on Celeb Rehab and really wants to be a singer?? Great role model…!!?? Shame on you Tyra for doing this to Angelea!

Angelea hold your head up high and use this publicity (good & bad) to your advantage and tell everyone to kiss your butt!!

December 8, 2011 at 11:31 am
(35) jenny says:

Angelea is trash. I believe the only reason that she was on the show was to keep some controversy going and keep people watching to see what she would do next. She has absolutely no class and couldn’t properly represent any company. Can you imagine having her as a “spokes model”? LOL. How many times would she blurt out f__k and b__ch in a professional setting or ask where the toilet is? Lisa shouldn’t have won either, she is a complete egomaniac. I believe Allison or Laura should have won, they are both real and sincere. And they both have class and carry themselves well. I’m sorry that they were sent home.

December 8, 2011 at 11:42 am
(36) Meka says:

Angelea should have been disqualified. Like any other job you have with contracts it’s certain things you can doand some you can not. She violated her contract. They knew what the consequences were for doing so and evidently she did not care. So the only person she can blame is herself.

December 8, 2011 at 11:54 am
(37) mec says:

I am happy that it turned out this way because she was so irritating!!! I wanted Allison to win, but Lisa is okay too. I would have reconsidered watching the show if Angelea had won. She wasn’t the best at anything except the blog, and there are people to help you with a blog if you need it.

December 8, 2011 at 11:57 am
(38) Judy Seaberry says:

The ending was a total shock. The whole season was a downer (in my opinion). I don’t know if All-stars works with the ANTM format.

December 8, 2011 at 12:00 pm
(39) Dee says:

Im so glad Angelea didn’t win, to much of a Hot Head! What she was claiming to be personality was Ghetto at its best. She wasn’t ready anyway— I think Lisa was a all around “Star” exactly what the All-Star title was looking for. Yes I think Angelea should have been disqualified for her actions. Be professional chick!

December 8, 2011 at 12:04 pm
(40) Christine C says:

Rules are rules and are in place for a reason. If she did win the title, then SHE lost it. No one else is to blame. They all know the rules going in. And to announce it on FB? Stupid!

December 8, 2011 at 12:08 pm
(41) Kat says:

Sorry people, but a contract is a contract!!!!! specifies what you can and cannot do. Besides…boy was she over confident; and in my opinion full of it( Angelie)!!!!! That big mouth finally got her what she deserved. Congrats to the winner!!!

December 8, 2011 at 12:45 pm
(42) Anna says:

Everything happens for the best. In this case Angelea will probably end up getting all kinds of interviews and attention because of her disqualification and all the contraversy it will lead to. Lisa did however, deserve to win as she really is the most talented of all the contestants. Congrats Lisa!!!

December 8, 2011 at 12:52 pm
(43) Rachel says:

Angelea had some type of deal with BET that disqualified her.

December 8, 2011 at 12:56 pm
(44) Scottie says:

If she indeed was the original winner at least be fair and help kick off her career. I reviewed her Facebook page and did not see anything unless removed. I do not believe she premeditated to scoop the names of the final three but acted as any young girl who is beyond excited with the events taking place in her life and the thought of how this could give her the chance of a life that she at one time could only have dreamed of and thus sharing her excitement with her fans. Lisa did announce on the last show that she should be the winner and by whatever means she at 30 old years did accomplish it, enjoy actual second place.

December 8, 2011 at 12:58 pm
(45) Mel says:

Lisa deserved it, she worked harder than anyone there! She has the star quality! Angelea is an emotional bomb waiting to explode. She doesn’t have the star quality that Allison and Lisa has. If Angelea won, I’m sure a lot of ANTM fans would be furious!

December 8, 2011 at 1:05 pm
(46) Lali B. says:

I think that it was totally unfair for Angelea to have been disqualified for fb….i mean really there has been far worse events to take place on ANTM. She didnt tell who won, so i mean really what was the big deal?! I really admired her drive and her fight…I would advise her to never give up, because she is the true ALL STAR!!!

December 8, 2011 at 1:06 pm
(47) Berdo says:

Thanks god, Angelea has disqualified. I just hate her. She diverves this. She’s just ungly bitch.

December 8, 2011 at 1:09 pm
(48) Charlotte says:

I am not sure who would have won. All I know is Angelea get’s disqualified because of something “she shared” with the producer and with that they decided to disqualify her. Maybe it was their shared plan to do this and boost rating…because they are not that good and if you noticed she received more face time then anyone….and it looked as though she was favored to win. I think she was just a pawn in their game. That is why she call Tyra a “Media——-”. I don’t think that she leaked anything because nothing ever showed up. I just feel bad that she was humiliated like this. She was humiliated enough with the Allison and Lisa fan’s talking about her so bad. Now this….I pray that her future is properous beyond this. I pray lots of BLESSINGS FOR YOU ANGELEA!!!!!!!

December 8, 2011 at 1:18 pm
(49) DIDI says:


December 8, 2011 at 1:31 pm
(50) Deb says:

Something is rotten in Denmak. People can speculate all they want. I don’t believe for a second that Angelea was dumb enough to reveal the results on facebook, and I am NOT a fan of hers. Anyone else remember the scene immediately following the final runway show. The other two were wired, geeked, stoked; on a natural high or adrenaline rush from the show. Angelea was sitting by hersef looking like her world had come to an end. They may have edited Lisa’s comments about that in, but the scene was real. I don’t think Angelea has what it takes to be a to model. She’s very crude, despite the fact that she’s been on the show three times and knows what they’re looking for. Some say it was racially motivated. Seriously? Did they miss all the other black girs who, and rightfully so, in the past? If it was as simple as her revealing the winner, why would they be so close-mouthed about it. Someone speculated that maybe she did something else deliberately. That’s actually a very logical assumption, and possibly a smart move on her part. look at all the attention she’s getting. As long as she didn’t do anything that can get her in legal trouble, maybe it was a smart business move on her part. She’s crude, and she has the morals of an alley cat, but she’s by no means stupid. You don’t survive in the environment she came from if you’re stupid. I think Laura should have won. I think she took better pictures. She never complained. She didn’t engage in the drama in the house. She stayed true to her self. She is an all star, and a person I as a mother would want my daughter to look up to.

December 8, 2011 at 1:34 pm
(51) Juanita says:

I think Lisa is so ugly drunk and weird. Angelea should have bwon. Angelea is clearly the fan favorite. I don’t usually watch this show but they had Marathon on the other day. I was bore and I watch.

December 8, 2011 at 1:56 pm
(52) loser says:

i agree that lisa shouldn’t have won, but i do not believe Angelea would have won if she wasn’t disqualified. Her overall body of work and poor personalirty would have clearly made allison the winner. all three girls desereved it though so i wish the best to all three of them.

December 8, 2011 at 2:27 pm
(53) Adrastos says:

Angelea did not deserve to win. Funny how towards the end of the cycle, they were saying good things about her.
I think her attitude was awful and she should be ashamed of herself. But now, she was so close, because we knew she was going to win, but because she is such a dumbell, she got her ghetto behind dis-qualified.

what a loser. Angelea, your a ghetto loser and will always be a loser.

December 8, 2011 at 2:33 pm
(54) Rose Pryer says:

I cannot believe what I heard during the finale of ATM. If Angelea won, why could she not have been reprimanded. I don’t read her facebook page as well as millions of other viewers. I am not interested in watching anymore, I have watched the show since the beginning, but I will be watching something else next season. Good luck Tyra! Angelea, I wish that you were the official winner. I was rooting for you girl!!!

December 8, 2011 at 2:34 pm
(55) Nicci says:

They sign contracts and have terms and conditions for a reason. Every show does. If you violate them there is consequences. It was extremely foolish of her to reveal any sort of information about the show prior to its air date. As much as it truly must suck to be disqualified, she made the decision to post the results and in return lost the title, the huge prizes, and her dreams. I feel their decision to disqualify her is fair. In the real world that is what happens when you breach a contract. There are consequences. Lisa may have been the winner by default, but nevertheless is still the winner. However, Lisa doesn’t seem surprised that she won, so she may have been the true winner the entire time. Unfortunately, we will never know unless Angelea posts that on face book as well.

December 8, 2011 at 2:35 pm
(56) N. Harper says:

My thoughts keep wondering if the allegations that Angelea posted something to the effect that she was the winner are true, then perhaps she was provoked as a response from Lisa’s constant unflattering remarks about her. Lisa must have been on camera at least 3 to 4 times during the finale show stating that she didn’t believe Angelea was ready, able, qualified to be America’s Next Top Model All Star. Who is Lisa to be saying these things and why was she broadcast saying this so many times? Perhaps Lisa’s constant insults provoked Angelea to prove she had what it takes. Perhaps Lisa manipulated this whole outcome knowing Angelea was insecure. That is my theory, if indeed, Angie posted the results on her fB page. Any one of the girls could have won, but my heart was hoping it would be Angelea. Lisa didn’t need this as much and had so much talent and presence and now exposure, she already is a star. Lisa may even be more qualified, but I disliked Lisa’s constant disapproval of Angelea. It was unattractive and unkind.

December 8, 2011 at 2:37 pm
(57) Leslie says:

I’m glad she was disqualified! She was a ticking time bomb. I’m sure her inability to keep her mouth shut would’ve pissed off a client eventually. She should just try getting an education and finding success that way. She was a little short on class anyway.

December 8, 2011 at 2:49 pm
(58) patricia says:

She open her mouth and she violate the contract. PERIOD. U dont get that close and screw up an chance like that. I think they did the right thing. But Liza should have not won. Liza behavior is going to make them regret they made her the winner. Watch what I say.

December 8, 2011 at 3:12 pm
(59) ella dukes says:

First of all the hoop la is not about Angeleque or Lisa or Allison. It’s about Italian Vogue, they are preduce. They do not want women of color posted on the front of their magazine. They are the sponsors and Tara and the rest of them do what they tell them to do. If Angelique guessed the 3 finalist so what, if she found out from the judges and told it, well then they should not have told her who the finalist was in the first place. The way the program has been going nobody knows who the finalist or the winner will be besides Tara, but all of a sudden that has changed when a woman of color was about to win after 3 white women won back to back and the only thing that changed all of that was she told something she wasn’t supposed to know in the first place or she guessed correctly. Wow! Italian Vogue must think all Americans just fell off the turnip truck!!!!! I think America’s Next Top Model has run its course. When your sponsors become so big and important they outweight the purpose of the show to begin with which was to give women/girls a chance. Then its time to dispand the program.

December 8, 2011 at 4:02 pm
(60) Teep says:

Rules are rules and they are to be followed! If you start allowing people to break them.. It would cause more problems with future shows.

December 8, 2011 at 4:03 pm
(61) laurie says:

What a waste of my TIVO space! They reshot the ending and handled it so poorly.

Lisa appears old and hard! She is not a model nor an all star. This season seemed like they all just coasted to collect money and didnt care about the audience or quality of output.

December 8, 2011 at 4:11 pm
(62) Ivan says:

Angelea was one of the strongest models, whether or not people want to accept it. I can recall her taking one so-so photo. From a picture standpoint, there hasn’t been a more consistent model (including their original cycles). She also had some intangibles that made her a good candidate. Her problem is that maybe she wants it too badly…she’s desperate. This would have changed her life forever, and she lets her life hinge on the decisions of these judges. There’s a reason no agency wanted to sign her after her cycle. She hasn’t developed the maturity.

Angelea strikes me as the type who would get caught up in the stardom, sleep with all the male celebs, spend all of her money, use drugs, get frustrated, or throw temper tantrums in front of big name clients like Max Factor. Just because you have talent doesn’t mean that you should be in show business. She would definitely struggle with the “business” part.

Angelea is a lot like Fantasia – exceptionally talented but lacks the savvy and maturity to navigate the entertainment world. I would throw Bianca, Camille and Jade into that category, as well.

The strongest models talent-wise were Angelea, Allison, Brittany, Bree, Bianca, Camille, Dominique, and Laura. Lisa was also strong…in a Lauren Hutton type of way.

December 8, 2011 at 4:58 pm
(63) A fan of ANTM says:

Angelique is the winner of Antm! I do not care what no one say!

December 8, 2011 at 5:18 pm
(64) kmlwa says:


December 8, 2011 at 5:26 pm
(65) CeCe says:

It seems you have to have some kinda sob story to win ANTM. Normal girls with no drama don’t win anymore. Allison by far had the best pictures. Angelea and Lisa both had the tranny look.

December 8, 2011 at 5:28 pm
(66) JUDY ALBRIGHT says:


December 8, 2011 at 5:33 pm
(67) chrissy says:

this top model was far the worse.. seriously all u people are happy that lisa won??? YUCK.. she was the ugliest one, less classy one, most annoyest one.. jesus christ the bitch peed in a diaper and was drunk half the show on her season… yuck and u guys want her to be a role model???? she should have never been on the show!!

December 8, 2011 at 5:54 pm
(68) tv says:

Lisa deserved to win… She had it ALL !!!!!!!!!!!!!! Angelea was a total train wreck.

December 8, 2011 at 6:10 pm
(69) nene says:


December 8, 2011 at 6:44 pm
(70) benesea says:

angeles is a hater and should not win beceuse she is a cry baby

December 8, 2011 at 7:06 pm
(71) vaughan says:

if angelea was the real winner, this show is a complete joke. jesus, have you seen her? she can’t take any criticism , she’s acting like a total bitch and crying 24/7. role model? no freaking way. and now lisa won? oh-my-god. ridiculous. she is not pretty, she is super annoying. she is not charismatic. she canno’t be a role model, just like angelea. the judges are crazy as hell. they kicked out lovely models like laura for them? … i am so disapointed. tyra banks, you lost your mind.

December 8, 2011 at 7:31 pm
(72) jeff says:

I agree with juliejohnson, Laura should have won. She was by far the prettiest and most talented, Allison next.

Angelea and Lisa weren’t pretty at all although they both are multitlalented and should be on ET or something like that. I think Angelea had the best song..she should release it as a single. It would be a hit!

December 8, 2011 at 7:34 pm
(73) Outraged says:

Ya’ll are crazy if you think Angelea’s whiney attitude deserved to win in the first place. It was all about her constant crying and all she ever did was complain about her poor background.
I used to get beat and locked out of my house while people were inside doing drugs, and I dont CONSTANTLY bring it up. She’s weak and I’m glad something disqualified her because to be honest if she would have won I would have lost all respect for the show. She was the worst throughout the ENTIRE cycle and she cried her way into the top despite her rude outbursts and ugly attitude. I say congrats to Lisa; and Allison was the most beautiful one in my opinion.

December 8, 2011 at 8:23 pm
(74) Ellen says:

What kind of example does that set if she broke her contract. because it’s not ok to lie.Who Cares who won anyway. At least they made it as far as they did

December 8, 2011 at 8:26 pm
(75) GeckoHiker says:

Gee, what an awful set of choices for a Cover Girl contract: Lisa or Angelea. Cover Girl doesn’t really need either former hard living drug addicts or hard living ghetto rats as role models because there are many other edgier role models that are more admirable. As for Allison, there are contacts she can wear that can protect her eyes from excessive exposure to light. I think way too much was made of that. A lot of light skinned people can’t stare at the sun and keep their eyes wide open. There is a reason for that.

December 8, 2011 at 8:34 pm
(76) TAMMY says:

Angelea is a girl with a big mouth that learned to late in life that there comes a time and a place to keep your trap shut, she is a grown ass woman and should know better. Its great that she got busted and disqualified because she would have not been a great role model or even a top model. She showed her true shyster side and she got what she deserved. Hooray to Lisa, this is a girl who use to be a wild child and grew the hell up, props to her!!!

December 8, 2011 at 9:21 pm
(77) Dawn says:

I think Angelea should have respected the confidentiality agreement if that was the case…however she may have been caught up in the moment and wanted to share the news if she was indeed the winner, but this is business and BUSINESS is BUSINESS. I think they did the right thing by letting her go. In my opinion she is a beautiful girl but still has some growing to do as a model emotionally.

December 8, 2011 at 9:32 pm
(78) SMMFH.. -__- says:

I think Alison should have won..great fotos,shes dorky,awkward,&unique looking many girls like that think their nothing she cld of been a great rolemodel..a/w im guessing the girls already knew who will win 1or2weeks before..so the shows a fraud -.-.

December 8, 2011 at 9:38 pm
(79) Patti says:

We all hated Angelea. She did not deserve to win anyhow. Somebody said it best: she was an emotional train wreck. I’m thinking they discovered she was taking drugs. My fave was Allison, but oh well. She will be an amazing star anyway. With all the athletic competitions, it seems the judges were favoring Lisa and giving her an edge the whole time. I didn’t like All-Stars; it was like MTV X3: too much hype: what with Tyra sucking her finger and saying “want some?” Give me a break–is the audience 12 years old? ANTM needs to return to its former dignity (dignity for a reality show). And that runway show was simply unfair and ridiculous. I still love allison; she’s awesome. And could someone explain Mr. Leon Tally to me. Who is he and why can’t he wear anything but bed sheets? They don’t say much for his fashion sense: they certainly don’t make him look slimmer! How could Angelea have won originally? Makes no sense. Excuse my criticisms: I still love ANTM but they need to calm down and lose the candy corn next season. There are adults watching.

December 8, 2011 at 9:41 pm
(80) Karen says:

It’s too bad she made it as far as she did. She is an emotional wreck and never had anything good to say about anyone. I was rooting for Allison and Laura. Sometimes I wonder what the judges are thinking. Espescially when they don’t follow instruction and do what they are suppose to do.
Congrats to Lisa and good luck.

P.S. Nice going bitch

December 8, 2011 at 9:50 pm
(81) starlight88 says:

like seriously thats why they disqualified her that’s soo dumb…………………seriously boooo Lisa you only won by default

December 8, 2011 at 9:51 pm
(82) Ashey says:

Angelea could not have been able to handle the responsibilities that came along with the prizes as she made very evident through whatever she leaked. Whether, she won or not. She is receiving too much press. She knows what she is doing and she is receiving more press than the winner which was her goal all along.
Lisa was already famous. She already had ways of earning money and making her fame known. The only reason she wanted to win was to promote her music she even said that on the show.
I find it so funny that everyone thinks that Lisa is good cause she will be a role model. I’m glad she overcame her past and everything, but what about Allison. She gave hope to all shy, timid girls who are afraid they can’t do anything because they are so introverted. However, she has made it so close everytime and hasn’t won because she is “shy.” I’m sorry, but she was the most respectable person on the show and Tyra crushed people’s dreams with that choice.

December 8, 2011 at 9:56 pm
(83) Smmfh says:

*Allison<3 or Laura should of won* not lisa or Ang..this damn show is a fraud..ima still watch it though e.e ..we got the alcoholic&drama queen..really? SMMFH..slap yoself ANTM people -____-

December 8, 2011 at 10:04 pm
(84) feuzz says:

what the hell, cannot believed, why duo???
love Angelea so proud of her :)

December 8, 2011 at 10:12 pm
(85) Sarah says:

Angelea never deserved to win, in fact, I was surprised that she even made it into the top three. To be honest, Laura or Dominique should’ve won! Lisa was good, but I don’t think she was the strongest…The whole season was terrible, All-Stars just doesn’t work with ANTM. Anyways, I do sort of feel bad for Angelea. Can you imagine winning and then lose your title just because of a dumb facebook post? But, she went against her confidentuality agreement, and proper steps needed to be taken.
All-in-all i think that ANTM has run it’s course, I’m starting to get bored with it and will not be watching next season.
Good luck to all of the girls in their future endavors! If they made it to All-Stars, they sure as hell had to be good.

December 8, 2011 at 10:13 pm
(86) nice says:

Yes angelea should have won she was the most prettiest and well groomed to be an allstar winner. That’s y for a couple of years I stop watchin top model cause of these shenanigans, so guess what now that a great model didn’t get choosen again I’m back to continuing not watchin again. Lisa is helle ugly and didn’t deserve it point blank gn!!!!!!

December 8, 2011 at 10:17 pm
(87) Raquel says:

Angelea did not deserve to be in the top three. I agree with some other comments that she was just kept around for an entertainment factor. There’s a reason she was in the bottom two so many times. Laura or Dominique should have had her spot.

December 8, 2011 at 10:22 pm
(88) Sarah says:

Lisa is so annoying. Does she ever stop talking… her yapping should have disqualified her. But really Angelic should have won.

December 8, 2011 at 10:33 pm
(89) angeleyes says:

Lisa deserved it, hands down. She has it all going on, she’s the only one I could see on Extra and her runway was great. Even IF Angelique did win it, she proved by her actions her immaturity and lack of control. Enough already, begone. WAY TO GO LISA!!!!!!!!!

December 8, 2011 at 10:46 pm
(90) Keimonte says:

Angelea shouldn’t have even made it as far as she did, Dominque should of made it instead of her

December 8, 2011 at 10:57 pm
(91) Chrissy says:

The finale was poorly done. Lisa clearly didn’t look genuinely surprised and its unfortunate Angelea didnt respect the terms of her contract. The whole thing is sigh-worthy.

December 8, 2011 at 11:06 pm
(92) Jamie says:

Maybe it was more than just breaking her contract. No one has actually confirmed that she leaked the top 3 results.

December 8, 2011 at 11:07 pm
(93) Maria says:

Angelea was the clear winner of the 3…lisa looked old and weathered..what was this america’s next top model oldies???

December 8, 2011 at 11:11 pm
(94) Belladonna says:

ALLISON!!!! She SOOO should have won because she was the best model and a great role model. After that, Laura should have won and gotten second place at least. She should have been in the finals. Lisa is okay i guess, but not my favorite. she deserved it somewhat, but nothing like the others. I HATE Angelea. She was such a bitch and was always complaining and she looked weird on that last episode, and not in a good way. In a ‘im on meth’ way. It was bad. Maybe that’s why she was disqualified. She did drugs. Wouldnt put it past her. And im not trying to be judgemental, but that’s the way she acted and said, Im just drawing inferences. If she has a problem she can suck it. Go Allison! I love you and look up to you so much. You were my favorite on all the cycles and deserved to win, not only here, but on your own cycle. I love you girly. You too, Laura. And Angelea can just go bleep herself. I hate her.

December 8, 2011 at 11:29 pm
(95) A.Ellis says:

Angelea should of won!! Point blank!!!

December 8, 2011 at 11:47 pm
(96) OneVoice says:

It’s consistent with other reality shows. Gabriel Iglesias was disqualified from Last Comic Standing for violating their terms and he is hugely famous, because he had the talent. If she truly has what it takes to be a successful model she will be.

December 8, 2011 at 11:49 pm
(97) Sarah says:

I can’t wait to find out what really happened. But here’s my 2 cents…. Angelea was so not a bitch. She was sweet, charming and funny. She didn’t constantly talk trash about any other contestants (like Lisa) and she was a total package. Yes, she was slightly rough around the edges sometimes, but when it came to business she did great. She won the medical challenge in front of camera, won the blog writing challenge and turned it up when it was business time. Allison is also great. Would have been happy with either 2 winning. Lisa on the other hand….WTF?????? Seriously Tyra? She’s old, haggard looking, a total bitch and a horrible role model!!

December 9, 2011 at 12:01 am
(98) Puck says:

I was terrified that Angelea was going to win anyway. I actually breathed a sigh of relief when she just mysteriously disappeared. There were many photo shoots that she should have lost (the singing video contest or, most importantly, the Olympic games shoot where Nigel actually had to coach her and MOVE HER ARMS). She was foul mouthed and crude and didn’t take great photos. Her runway walk/swim was awkward. Her stiff posing made Allison look swan like. Dominique definitely deserved to be there more than Angelea, yet, mysteriously, the judges kept her around. I couldn’t figure out what they saw in her and was dreading that she would win. I liked Lisa and felt she worked really hard and had some fabulous ugly/pretty shoots.

December 9, 2011 at 12:13 am
(99) Hottie says:

Angelea knew better, this is not the first time she was on ANTM. It happens to the best of us. Angelea let this be a lesson in humility. I know you were happy about the top 3 and winning the overall competition, but if there is ever a next time. JUST BE QUIET!!!!!!

December 9, 2011 at 12:28 am
(100) Tia says:

Yes, Angelea was on an emotional roller coaster but she pushed through to the end. It’s obvious they keep girls based on the drama they can bring to the show and both Lisa and Angelea delivered. The show is still interesting and has more integrity than Project Runway which I stopped watching when they created a so-called alumni show just to give 100k to the worst designer with ties to 2 of the judges.

Talk about crude, ghetto and tacky — does peeing in an adult diaper on camera that you were using in a photo shoot – count? That’s what the current Top Model Lisa did in her first cycle on the show. Beyond being disgusted, I thought she should have been sent home that day and I was shocked to see them bring her back. Today, she’s the luckiest B%$& in America!!

December 9, 2011 at 12:31 am
(101) that guy says:

I don’t think Angelea actually won, they just had to reshoot the judging panel without her. She’s too fragile and sensitive to be a Top Model All Star.

December 9, 2011 at 12:34 am
(102) nkr1 says:

Wow, how dumb does she feel now.

December 9, 2011 at 12:37 am
(103) livimo says:

Angelea shouldn’t have even been in the top 3. she was too emotional, rude, and frankly, not even attractive. Lisa isnt that attractive either to be honest… but when it comes down to the cover girl persona, the top model persona, and of course being marketable and “high fashion” i believe the clear winner was allison. she was the whole package AND the most “high fashion”. all in all, the top 3 should have been laura, lisa, and allison. I can’t believe angelea even made it that far.

December 9, 2011 at 1:06 am
(104) M.Bella says:

I don’t think Angelea was the winner in the first place. Anyone notice how rehearsed Lisa & Allison’s reactions were? To me, it seemed like they already knew who the winner was in the first place, they just went along with the show. The finale was probably just re-done as to purposely exclude Angelea from it because she broke the agreement.

December 9, 2011 at 1:08 am
(105) mel says:

no way she won, she was hanging on by a thread anyway.

December 9, 2011 at 1:29 am
(106) AO says:

If it’s true that Angelea was disqualified for violating her confidentiality agreement then I think it is a fair decision. As a professional model, the ladies will be put into many situations where they have to understand the business and legal rules. It is unfortunate but it won’t impact her ability to go forward with a great career. She is the only one standing in her way.

December 9, 2011 at 1:35 am
(107) Robin says:

Lisa should have not won, regardless of who was in the top three or two, yes she is talented, but not the most talented or relatable. I’m sick of hearing that she went through hard times as a child so now she is the only one deserving of the title. News Flash you are not the only survior, the world is full of us, and most of us went through worst with out all of the ups and downs you seem to have put yourself through the past years, get over yourself and then find humility. Allison, i wanted you to win very much, sorry ! I hope to see you in my magazines soons. Ms. Banks, Mr. Tally, Mr. Barker, you made the wrong choice, it hasnt been your first nor i guess your last but i hope it occures less in the future.

December 9, 2011 at 2:21 am
(108) Lee says:

Some blogs are stating Angelea may be pregnant because of a statement Jay made during a shooting that she was having trouble holding in her stomach. She would not be able to keep the commitments if that is the case. When looking at the segment between Allison and Laura standing there at judging, Allison in no way looked like a top model and I was floored when she was chosen. I’m certain that Tyra is more upset about this mess then we are thinking about.

December 9, 2011 at 3:11 am
(109) Yo says:

Couldn’t stand Angelea and her whining and I never thought Lisa was pretty. Lisa was manly looking with a somewhat large nose. I think Laura should have won ANTM and was shocked she wasn’t in the top three.

December 9, 2011 at 4:39 am
(110) ha guy says:

Angelea never belonged in the top 3. She was in the bottom more times than anyone in top model history. I counted 4 separate time. She was a ticking time bomb. I am just sad that what ever she did she wasted everyone’s time and took Lara’s chance away. I’m glad I will never have to see her melt down ever again. She was so fake. Though Allison was my favorite Lisa did stick to her brand and that is why she won.

December 9, 2011 at 5:41 am
(111) shayParker says:

Angelea won. Its unnreal how Nigel ALWAYS went out of his way to down Angelea, or make negative comments about her. Lisa was absolutely nutts. Angelea really wanted to win. So what her emotions took over she was giving her all. Until you have walked in her shoes (Nigel) dont criticize her, at all. I also found it rather unusual that Nigel, with his smirk across is lips, announced that Angelea was not going to be in the judging process. It was as if he was saying, Ha Ha I got her(Angelea) finally. Tyra, I was your biggest fan, never missing a show because I felt you were so genuine, but now I agree with the other fans…YOU ARE A FAKE! I will no longer be supporting you or your shows. Angelea hold your head up Lisa didnt win….YOU DID!!!

December 9, 2011 at 6:44 am
(112) Aundria says:

If you can’t uphold a contract, don’t enter into one! Simple as that! By default or NOT, Lisa is the winner! Although Laura and Shannon were always my favorites:)

December 9, 2011 at 6:45 am
(113) Heather says:

Yes, disqualify. I do think in all fairness to ANTM fans, if this was the true reason, it should be made public. Others should learn from her error in judgement. Ps I can’t stand Lisa’s obnoxious behavior.

December 9, 2011 at 7:28 am
(114) JBenn says:

Of course she deserved to be disqualified!!! You would think with so much at stake that one would be able to keep their mouth shut. She made a mistake and should be held accountable for her actions. Someone who is top model material is someone who can compose thenselves in a professional manner, and what she did is completely unprofessional. For that reason alone the other two girls deserved to be there more than her.

December 9, 2011 at 7:40 am
(115) Tara says:

This is not fair at all…I pray that Angelea can heal from this…Its something to think that she would of won because I knew all along, thats how much faith I had in her..She totally fits the title America’s Next Top Model Allstar….I dont know who made the call on that but it was a stupid one..and Lisa winning made my flesh crawl

December 9, 2011 at 8:11 am
(116) ME says:

All the Angelea haters…BOW DOWN in that order

December 9, 2011 at 8:31 am
(117) Teresa says:

I personally can’t stand Angelea. She was annoying and immature. i was going for laura. They made a huge mistake cutting her. I think that if they cut Angelea they should of brought Laura back in to compete with the top 3. She is who iwould of picked. Lisa is just outright annoying too.

December 9, 2011 at 8:32 am
(118) Jackie says:

It is quite unfortunate for Angelea. In was rooting for her. You have to have the ability to be mature and honor requests made of you. When you sign a contract you must be able to hold up your side of the agreement. This was not a game! This was REAL, but Angelea’s immaturity showed again andvas a result, shevwas disqualified. Oh Well!

December 9, 2011 at 8:44 am
(119) Cherry says:

I rather have Allison won than all the rest of the girls. She is stunning in all her works. But, Liza was my second choice coz she has the package (all-in-one beauty, brain, talent, maturity and compose). Angelea??? she has too much dramas/issues that she need to deal with it first. For me, as far as i saw parts of the competition, she never proved anything to be called America’s Next Top Model at all.

December 9, 2011 at 9:38 am
(120) Anthony Jones says:

Im a huge fan of this show and I say she still should have been able to keep her title. Donald trump let the Miss America keep her title after the scandal she was involved in. Hey I guess thats show biz but Lisa will never be able too feel the way she wanna feel. Which is a real true winner and Model something we all know she isnt.

December 9, 2011 at 9:44 am
(121) Carrie says:

The re-shoot of the ending was horrible! I gathered from the re-shoot and their body language and expressions that Angelea won originally. And you could tell by Lisa’s reaction, and Allison’s, that neither were really excited because they knew they weren’t the true winners. Lisa kept saying “I won’t let you down” which is tell-tale that she felt like she failed them originally (since she wasn’t original winner) and a stab at Angelea. And that made me want to throw up. Fi what Tyra and the rest preach as a ture model is truth, Angelea didn’t have what it took, especialloy to be considered an All-Star. Neither did Lisa or Allison. I agree with so many others it should have been Laura. That girl had it all!!! Everyone has their opinions, and are entitled to them, but for those of you who say Angelea’s “mistake” should have been overlooked or forgiven, what I can say to you is it is people like you that have sent our society down the toilet. Integrity is so important and so ffew people have it nowdays. Entitlement and excuses have taken over and lack of accountability are ruining us. At least Tyra got it right by disqualifying her. Other than that, this whole thing was a huge disappointment all the way around.

December 9, 2011 at 10:08 am
(122) Pete says:

Angelea should never had made it this far let alone in the All-Star group. There is nothing about her that says Cover Girl or model for me.

The battle should have been between Allison and Lisa after Dominique and Laura were cut. Though I still would have rather had Allison win this without question, Lisa did have a better end result in the final spots. Though overall I still think Allison was far better and should have been declared the winner in Greece…

December 9, 2011 at 10:43 am
(123) Shashe says:

If she broke contract confidentiality agreements, she definitely should have been disqualified. She should have kept her big mouth shut. Why anyone would blow such an opportunity is beyond me. She really messed up the finale for me because she wasn’t there; too bad she was so selfish and only thought about herself. Clearly she was the better of the three in my opinion.

December 9, 2011 at 11:19 am
(124) dani says:

Angelia knew the rules, this is a lesson learned
To shut your mouth. Lisa did great, and followed the rules. She was also classy, that can not be said about A.

December 9, 2011 at 11:27 am
(125) Maxx says:

Wel there she ges and blows it, if she was the winner, hence this is why when you sign all the docs on the show it includes confidentiality, she whined and complained, and had some issues that worked to her advantage, but if your going to leak something like that on Facebook really makes for poor sportsmanship, infact they should have eliminated her a long time ago, she was thin ice, and this proved it, so to those that think she should have won, look at the past epsisodes and see how she was safe from elimination, yet in this finale airing poof, only goes to show you that this individual obviously was peggged by Lisa all along that she is not ready.
If peeps are going to feel sorry for this person well get over it, considering she knew the rules for when he was competing the last time, so it i not new to her! so she knew the rules twice over, heck if yoru that dumb (Angelea) and you were saying you wanted it so bad, well look at you now, but take it and reveal it on facebook, smart move! so doing that really never gave the girl a chance to continue because the judges had faith in you then poof dont think you will be going back to ANTM, well it shows everyone that your still immature to handle such huge things like that so long and LISA you deserved it anyway, your strong and Jay said you proved it, who wants a cry baby anyway.

December 9, 2011 at 11:36 am
(126) Lynda says:

The win did not seem authentic at all… the finale was a little disappointing. I also believe that Allison or Laura should have won…

December 9, 2011 at 11:51 am
(127) Kimberly says:

What is wrong with you people? Angelea violated her contract. The reason she got kicked off is becaue she told people that she had won prior to the last episode being aired. That is a violation of her confidentiality agreement. She got what she deserved. Back to the ghetto she goes. Typical hoodrat…talks too dam much and doesn’t know when to shut up! smdh

December 9, 2011 at 12:36 pm
(128) bebbie says:

Well obviously, it’s a melodramatic attitude towards one’s worship of the show. They must think we take the show to heart or something.

How many people does angelea have on facebook anyway? Out of all the reasons, this was quite pathetic.

On the other hand, what was angelea thinking, did she still need a memo that she’s in a tv show. It’s still dissapointing, because she technically won! Although I find Lisa and Angelea’s story quite rewarding, they both would have represented strong women and I think Angelea should have kept the title and learned an innocent and juvenile mistake.

December 9, 2011 at 1:16 pm
(129) Adrian says:

Angelea Broke the rules, therefore, she should not have gotten the title. Yeah, if Angelea was going to be the winner then Lisa won by default, but, hey, that’s what Angelea gets. You can’t just decide that the rules don’t apply to you and still reap the reward,

December 9, 2011 at 1:20 pm
(130) Storm says:

I am glad she was disqualified. She was an awful person and if she was the original winner, they really made a bad decision in the first place.

December 9, 2011 at 1:22 pm
(131) steffy says:

i think they were all winners!! it must have been so hard for the judges to choose between them. im glad lisa won she really worked for it. im sure we will be seeing alison and angelea in magazines real soon. good luck to all the americas next top models in training!! i will be watching!!:)

December 9, 2011 at 1:28 pm
(132) what a shame says:

I wanted anyone to win but lisa, for her to have gone thru so much in her life she should have been the most humble an understanding to the other girls who also have been thru some things instead of bashing them and making it like they weren’t worthy enough to be on the show. As for Angelea like others have said people make mistakes and alot of other models on the show have done things and it’s been overlooked so what’s the big deal. I understand about a contract but if she just told who the final 3 were hell we all watched the show and saw for ourselves who it was gonna be in the end. Well we will see how much Ms. Lisa be a role model because on a real she is still having issues with her past because she is so flighty and wilding out all the time that’s a front for im still not over what has happened to me. I believe she will not continue her career in modeling she really wants to be a rock star. As for the other girls i wish them all the best because they are ALL STARS!!!!!!!

December 9, 2011 at 2:08 pm
(133) Roberta says:


December 9, 2011 at 2:25 pm
(134) DM says:

I would think that in addition to beauty, runway and photo challenges, Ms. Banks would desire her models to enbody a high level of taste and intellectual training, exposure to the arts with a wide reputation of culture, accomplishments, refinement, knowledge, sophistication, manners, class, elegance, grace, taste, a true attempt for civility and common courtesy.

Angelea did not represent any of these traits nor was she a front runner in ANY of her photographs or did she have a strong runway walk. Instead, she made fodder for classless reality TV that all producers love. Angelea reflected unsophistication, coarseness, crudeness, vulgarity, lack of manners and values and an overall horrendous, (and loud!), “feel sorry for me” attitude.

December 9, 2011 at 2:46 pm
(135) ANTM EX-fan... says:

Angelea revealed the winner of ANTM All-Stars…which was herself. Lisa got 2nd and Allison got 3rd. Kinda why at the “re-shoot” Lisa didn’t seem too ecstatic and Allison was surprised. They had been through it once already. But Angelea breached her confidentiality contract so she was DQ-ed.
I used to LOVE ANTM but this season was it for me. Allison was the best choice from the remaining 3, and she didn’t win. Lisa’s personality was over the top and not any role model I would be interested. Laura, although 4th, would have been the best selection for this show. ANTM’s run is over. The judgings this season were all over the place and eliminations seemed off. In addition, this final ending was terrible. The judging didn’t seem real (it wasn’t!) and we didn’t even get to see the vogue pictures as well as it didn’t last very long because it was a re-shoot. ANTM fails. The end

December 9, 2011 at 2:56 pm
(136) Iris says:

I agree with Amber, Angelea did not seem emotionally stable enough to win Next Top Model, All Star

December 9, 2011 at 4:19 pm
(137) sarah says:

Angelea was white trash, im glad that bitch didn’t win and that they disqualified her.

December 9, 2011 at 4:36 pm
(138) Jennifer says:

A Pittman:
No one said she “lied” about anything. Apparently she violated a non-disclosure contract, which required her to keep quiet about details of the show.

December 9, 2011 at 4:48 pm
(139) Deborah says:

I think don’t think they should have been disqaulified. You don’t have to be refine to be a model, some of your best top models were from the hood and were very unrefined. Angelea new how to turn it off and turned it on….Good luck Angelea on your future endeavors.

December 9, 2011 at 5:47 pm
(140) shorti says:

I agree with Amber….how can a contestant who flies off at the handle at the smallest thing ever be considered to represent vogue, cover girl, Extra! ! Seriously!?????? she should’ve been gone and especially shouldn’t have been chosen over dominique. That decision was absolutely preposterous! It was always Lisa or Allison

December 9, 2011 at 6:06 pm
(141) CeCe says:

Angela should never have one. I don’t know if this has been said but she was in the BOTTOM 2, FOUR TIMES!! After the second time she should of been sent home. If anyone should have won it should have been Allison. She always got great critiques. The reason they gave for not picking her was totally bogus.

December 9, 2011 at 6:22 pm
(142) RayRay says:

Angelea was no near a model than I am. She’s a bull dog with way to much emotional baggage. I’m sooo glad she didn’t win. I couldn’t understand why Tyra seemed to favor her. Ewww…

Congrads to Lisa. She deserved it. As crazy as she was the first time around, Lisa was composed this time. She showed that she had grown as a person, and as a model. I still love Allison, either of the two would have been great picks.

December 9, 2011 at 6:36 pm
(143) Pook says:

Just because they redid the segment, doesn’t mean Angelea won. After all, she was there in the room when the winner was chosen, and it would’ve seemed a bit dumb to include her. Perhaps she made 2nd place, because Lisa didn’t seem too excited and Alison looked like she already knew the outcome. Not giving the win to Lisa would’ve been a huge mistake on the judges’ part. No one performed better than Lisa throughout. She consistently gave strong performances with photos, runway, commercials and her music. Honestly, Bre, Bianca, Laura and Dominque deserved it more than Angelea did. And Allison deserved it more, too. Angelea worked that “poor kid from the hood” routine to the hilt and it worked because they felt sorry for her. Bottom line, she was unstable and immature and while it’s debatable if she deserved to be part of the 3, let alone 2nd place, she surely didn’t deserve to win.

December 9, 2011 at 7:27 pm
(144) Pook says:

P.S. DM … loved your comment and I totally agree. I was rooting for Allison, basically because she looks more like a model than Lisa (although I do love Lisa), but Angelea didn’t look like a model at all to me. Nevertheless, 2nd and 3rd place gals always do well, so maybe they thought this was the last shot for Lisa (and it was) and Allison definitely got so much exposure, agencies will come to her. If they had chosen Angelea, it would be like Naima in cycle 4 all over again. Short of her great runway walk, she was the least exciting winner, IMO, of all the cycles, but Angelea would’ve topped her.

December 9, 2011 at 7:43 pm
(145) Chris says:

Lisa and Allison I picked as top 2 from day one anyway. And as much as AlleyCat was my fave model ever probably Lisa soooo deserved to win. She IS her brand and rocked the entire season in my opinion. Angelea was and is a hot mess.

December 9, 2011 at 7:59 pm
(146) martika says:

I wanted Laura (or Allison) to win – Angelea was a mess the whole cycle. Lisa has uber confidence, but in my opinion she seems ‘past her prime’ and it was showing in the covergirl ad/photos… If they wanted to ‘reshoot’ something, it should’ve been that campaign…her skin was very shiny/greasy looking and nothing about the commercial would ever convince me to buy that product – it looked horrible!! I feel like they picked the winner based on who was going to have the hardest time getting signed on their own – ie Laura is young, Allison is young = they have “time” on their side….Lisa (by model standards) is “old”.

December 9, 2011 at 8:10 pm
(147) bdarr says:

they got it right angelea did not deserve to win. i fig it would have been lisa but sometimes they choose the opposite of what u think. im glad it was between lisa and allison

December 9, 2011 at 9:56 pm
(148) JOYU says:


December 9, 2011 at 9:59 pm
(149) julius says:

ANGELEA should have won!!!!!!; I think that to be disqualified over something so idiotic is unfair!!. Give her the title!!!!

December 9, 2011 at 10:12 pm
(150) Michelle says:

I think the actual ending should have been shown, and then the new winner should have been decided. We don’t need to be faked out. She’s lucky they didn’t sue her, but they were malicious in holding back the footage demonstrating they initially thought she deserved to win. They not only leaked the rumor that she violated her confidentiality agreement; they killed her career.

December 9, 2011 at 10:13 pm
(151) JoZ says:

I have to admit, I was secretly rooting for Angelea. Even though I thought Lisa had the best energy, and I related most to Allison, Angelea definitely seemed to want it the most.

Allison has enough talent, creativity and fans to be fine without the title, and Lisa had the ambition of a winner. I just thought Angelea would have made a better story arch for the show…

Pretty bad move on her part though, but God I feel bad for her. It’s not like it was drugs or anything horrible…

However, I do understand how these contracts work. If you’re gonna be in the business, you’ve gotta play by their rules, and there’s no room for mistakes. Sigh.

December 9, 2011 at 10:54 pm
(152) Camille says:

Angelea the Top All Star Model? Hell no. I’m not hatin on her its just the fact she made a big deal out of everything. If she says shes strong then why the hell was she being so emotional about her past? That should have drove her more not push her back wasting the photographers time and the others time just because she was crying.
buck up or shut up.
And the fact she was saying that the others look down on her because they think shes a threat , damn girl dont be conceded! and i cant remember if she said they were hatin on her cuz she came from the ghetto, well get over yourself i highly doubt her case was the worst.
the worlds rough. it aint goin to stop to make sure she is alright.

besides her photos werent even good. i thought they were all practically the same. i like lisa but hers were a little bit on the same looks to it but it still looked good. i really liked allisons pictures and shes very talented but i really wish she was at least a little bit more motivated to do modeling rather than painting. i’m an artist myself but… if im more for art then id not bother going on that show and leave that spot open for a girl who really wants it.

December 9, 2011 at 10:56 pm
(153) Camille says:

And to those who think it would have been a better story arch for the show….. IT IS REALITY TV. they shouldnt make someone a winner just to make it more interesting. its for the real modeling business.

and there has to be something deeper than just revealing who the top 3 were.

December 9, 2011 at 11:57 pm
(154) jewey says:

Well I have watched ANTM since the beginning and this all stars, well it just made me feel I do not need to see this show anymore. Will not be a follower to injustice.

December 10, 2011 at 12:42 am
(155) angelina barr says:

well to me it kind of looked like angelee won. lisa always seemed to model the same poses and i feel she was too much of a train wreck. yes angelee did cry but lisa was crazy and the other girl couldn’t keep her dang eyes open in the sun. angelee was my fav from jump. plus i know the judging was fake, i felt like the girls already knew the results before they even stepped in the room.

December 10, 2011 at 3:00 am
(156) KJ says:

i see both side, but i do feel like LISA was and is the TRUE winner i love her and she deserved it.

December 10, 2011 at 3:06 am
(157) TheWillie says:

Haters will always hate, and achieve nothing other than wasted time being negative.

Lisa is America’s Next Top Model All Star.

End of story!!!

December 10, 2011 at 4:16 am
(158) Crystal says:

Angelea is an idiot, she should have known revealing something like that was going to screw her in the end. As far as im concerned she did it to herself, so she deserved it. The moral of the story? Dont be a gossip.

December 10, 2011 at 5:39 am
(159) choum says:

She did not deserve to win. the judges realized that theu have made a mystake

December 10, 2011 at 6:41 am
(160) likes educated role models says:

Angelea should have never been on All-Stars in the first place. Way to ghetto and an emotional train wreck to be anyone’s role model

December 10, 2011 at 8:57 am
(161) Dee says:

SHE wanted it more than anyone and yes she did complain a lot, but she’s young and still has a lot to learn. What I really want to know is WHY did she get disqualified? Don’t the viewers deserve to know?

December 10, 2011 at 8:58 am
(162) Janette says:

Angelea should never have made it as far as she did. She was ghetto, ugly and awkward! I would NEVER want my child, or anyone’s child, to look up to her. Tyra is someone kids should look up to! Not someone who can’t control themselves and try to be a reasonable, intelligent person.

December 10, 2011 at 10:18 am
(163) zahria says:

I wanted Allison to win!!!!! Go Allison!

December 10, 2011 at 10:49 am
(164) JeDawn G says:

I believe that Angalea deserved to win she had more heart than all the girls and she was emotional because she felt attacked by all the girls and she faced hardships in life with her family background. Lisa is great but she is not the real winner. Angalea is different, unique and beautiful she was chosen for a reason . And made a simple mistake aren’t we all human !

December 10, 2011 at 1:35 pm
(165) Stephanie says:

For whatever reason, I’m glad she was disqualified! She isn’t emotional ready or strong enough to handle modeling. She was to much drama for me, always doubting herself and crying. She annoys me!! I think Alison should’ve won!!!

December 10, 2011 at 3:15 pm
(166) Stephanie says:

If she violated a written/legally binding contract, the title was rightly taken away. Lisa has the whole package, anyone of thos ladies could’ve taken home the title, they were all very talented. I wish Angelea would’ve just held up too what the contract said, but unfotrunately she didn’t and due to her indescretions, she lost the title.

December 10, 2011 at 3:50 pm
(167) KSTAR says:

I am truly amazed by some of the senseless comments, Angelea like her or not is definitely a REAL working model, with personality, as someone in the fashion industry, I work with and live with real models, they are some crazy, edgy, unique, and emotional, for those saying she lacks refinement, haven’t been around real models, many of the top models on covers around the Globe, lack refinement in their personal persona. In this age of reality TV, emotion and personality means ratings, and the truth of the matter is that Angelea boosted ANTM’s ratings, she singlehandedly, had america tuning in each week, to view the drama she brought, but is disqualified for revealing the final three, is absolutely bananas, Tyra definitely got her moneys worth out her drama, each week, but can’t stand behind her in the minor mistake…Shame on you Tyra, and everyone involved, Angelea worked hard to get where she is..Everyone making negative comments, has mistakes in life,CHECK YOUR ON MIRRORS people, she’s human…

December 10, 2011 at 5:13 pm
(168) Delores says:

Lisa did not win she came in sloppy second

December 10, 2011 at 7:24 pm
(169) rosa says:

Umm, that sucks bad. I thought angelea should have won and then they just say she was disqualified. Poor Ali to lose all over again. Wtf. I’m done watching after that and I’ve been since cycle one

December 10, 2011 at 10:41 pm
(170) Pamela says:

I told myself that if Angelique wins the competition that I will never watch America’s next top model ever again and I meant it. And even now, I am still on the fence. As Mark mentioned she does not have the class and elegance of a model. She is completely ghetto and talks like a hooch. Not to mention that she is not beautiful in my eyes at all. She doesn’t have a versatile and unique look. Lisa actually looked the best that they ever showed in the finale. She looked beautiful and extremely poised. I also do not feel that Lisa should have won but she put up a solid competition and has a nice amount of energy. I was reading last night that Janice Dickinson stated that it is Cover girl who does that actual judging and that the competition is rigged. Not shocking, but another reason to be annoyed by this whole show. I can’t think of one model who has actually become a “super model” such as the completely pompous Tyra Banks. The show is entertaining to watch but at the same time it is embarrassing to watch as well. Regardless, I am happy that Angelique did not win because she just isn’t pretty enough. At all!

December 10, 2011 at 11:22 pm
(171) brownin says:

Lisa should NOT have won, and I wish she didn’t…..not fair at all, no lies came out out angael’s mouth, just a little mistake of top 3 not the winner!!!!!!

December 11, 2011 at 1:22 am
(172) juicyFruit says:

i know Angelea was always at bottom panel..but the truth of the matter is..if you can beat everyone at bottem panel then it suggest that your personality is so strong that it prevails everything…i can seee Angelea doing funny skits like Friday..polish her acting for a music video,,or even host a family show..BUt i give Lisa props becus she did work hard and she is rough around the edges but lisa can be a camemilian if she wanted..i just think all star had Angeleas essence written all over it…

December 11, 2011 at 1:28 am
(173) shaquanda says:

I have known one of the madeup artists who worked on the set of American next top model and this is how it went…..Angelea was annouced as the winner of this cycle but the show producer found out that slutty Angelea was flirting heavily with judge…Nigel Baker and trying to persuade his vote before the decision was made. The flirting went as far as Angelea was rubbing his ass and grabbing his nuts, oh well as you’all know all those gay judges aren’t into girls at all lol. Hence, slutty Angelea was disqaulified, plus she posted on her face book that she was the winner before the last episode was aired.

December 11, 2011 at 1:39 am
(174) Taylor says:

I don’t think she was ready for all stars in the first place, she was not emotionally ready for the whole journey.

December 11, 2011 at 3:55 am
(175) LC says:

Lisa Won and deserved to win. Angelea was the biggest whiner not winner of the show. Its sad that this controversy has to make people doubt Lisa’s Win.
They made a short movie for Tyra and it was announced the second portion of the movie would be shown at the end of the competition, and the end of the movie would show the winner. I do not believe Angelea was the winner, I do believe they had to cut her portion out of the final as she was disqualified for something that happened prior to the original shooting of the movie. Angelea had so many moments where she walked off a shoot as she was upset.(whining)She should have been gone long ago.
Rumor has it she told who was in the final or self-proclaimed herself the winner.
The real losers in all this was Laura and Dominique they outshined Angelea all the time.

December 11, 2011 at 5:31 am
(176) Twinkling peanuts says:

Angelea shud have never made it to the finals…..she was always bottom two…..and crying all over the place…..the judges are funny sometimes…..they let Dominique go coz she wasn’t memorable in one episode when she had won best photo in the previous but they kept angelea who was constantly in the bottom…..strange!!! She got tooo many chances that one……not too happy with Lisa winning but she is at least better than angelea….

December 11, 2011 at 12:13 pm
(177) ^URS says:

Simple mistake?! Why do people excuse because it was a simple mistake? Angelea has past experience with the contract from her cycle. And now, with All Stars it would follow the same guidelines. The real world has contracts and were you to break the specifics of that contract then it would only follow that you be fired. ANTM did just that. We have to remember that this show is nationwide and prospective bosses are out there watching and listening. The first thing they will realize of Angelea is that she can not keep her word even with a signed document to remind her. Nobody wants to works with someone they can not trust. Sure there are opinions about stability, maturity and class but those things will develop over time. Regaining trust however, that does not start you with your foot in the door, more like nailed to the floor.

December 11, 2011 at 12:22 pm
(178) Kathy says:

Angelea wasn’t a model and is and always will be an emotional train wreck! She never deserved the title!

December 11, 2011 at 12:44 pm
(179) Johnny says:

I agree with the other comments reflecting that the winner was something of a let down. Angelea did breach her contract. Therefore, she lost.

The big let down is that ANTM is becoming more Kardashian and Hollywood than real people being role models. Lisa is clearly the most extroverted personality and will make a great personality for anything that requires superficiality. Tyra, you should have listened to the fans – Allison was popular because she was sincere and authentic. She stood for something real. The show is no longer on my watch list. Seems like ANTM sold out and no longer represents Tyra’s original goal.

I laughed out loud when they commented on Allison’s “vacant” expression – the irony is that Lisa is clearly the vacant one. She’ll fit right in with “Extra” personalities. She certainly won’t fly at Italian Vogue.

December 11, 2011 at 2:09 pm
(180) Sam says:

NO – Most people arn’t pi**ed that Angelea was disqualified, she messed up…we are pissed at the lack of transparency has to WHY she was…surely as viewers we should get a kernel of what went down. It makes Tyra seem sneaky, and makes Lisa look like a fool getting sloppy seconds…

Angelea is “STILL THAT B**CH”!

December 11, 2011 at 3:32 pm
(181) Aarim says:

A contract it a contract. You sign it and you agree to the terms and conditions, as ridiculous as the terms might be. What’s wrong with you people? OF COURSE she should be disqualified; she violated a contract.

After all the pissing and moaning that Angelea did about deserving to win the competition for herself and everyone else, she went and f***ed it up for herself! She couldn’t keep her mouth shut. She is an idiot and deserved to have the title taken from her. it should not have been given to her in the first place.

December 11, 2011 at 4:58 pm
(182) Mia says:

Angelea is so stupid! Iwas rooting for her! She’s come a long way since her original cycle and I’m really just disappointed in her! Sure she was catty and had a bad attitude at times but she’s a good model and smarter than she lets on. If the reason behind her disqualification is that she leaked info abt her winning, then that’s just completely pathetic. All she had to do was keep her big mouth shut for a little while longer and she could’ve taken home those CoverGirl, Express and Vogue Italia contracts! Stupid, stupid Angelea! How could you!?

December 11, 2011 at 5:46 pm
(183) J Smoke says:

I dont know why anyone thinks Angelea should have even been considered for the show aside from her drama factor. She is a ghetto skank with no real talent, back bone or self control. She cant be a role model for any real person. She should have been the third person off the show from the begining.Allison or Lisa both deserved it.

December 11, 2011 at 6:24 pm
(184) S. Moore says:

Rules are rules. It really doesn’t matter if she originally won or not. She obviously had to sign a confidentiality agreement and she broke it. Not saying that she didn’t deserve to win, I’m just saying she’s lucky all they made her do was give up the title. They probably could’ve done much worse legally. She could’ve gotten sued by the producers or the CW. I hope she learned her lesson.

December 11, 2011 at 7:04 pm
(185) Singer1 says:

Lisa DID NOT deserve to win!!! Angela is the ALL STAR!!

December 11, 2011 at 7:27 pm
(186) Gare Bear says:


But if Angelea violated the contract, she should not win. Even if she didn’t, she still was NOT an all star.

Lisa’s ok..but Allison’s the real star

December 11, 2011 at 9:24 pm
(187) Britknow says:

It seems some people are getting their “facts ” about modeling from antm, and as a former model that JUST got out of the most cutthroat industry in the world, let me tell ya, antm is NOTHING like the real world of modeling. First of all, fashion models now are extremely this with incredibly pronounced bone structure and 98% of the girls who were on the show weren’t modelesque enough to ever be put on a runway. The truth is, out of the final 4, the only girl that will ever get booked for a real show or high fashion job IS angelea. The industry doesn’t give a crap how much singing talent you have, how much you show your personality at castings (they’d rather you be agreeable and quiet), and only care about looks and how those looks photograph. All that “modeling talent” Tyra spews is total nonsense. Being comfortable in front of a camera doesn’t require any talent, just decent self esteem or gracefulness. That’s it. And all these challenges are so utterly ridiculous I won’t even touch those. Truth is, out of the final four girls, Lisa is way too old, Laura is way too short and too commercial (I love her but again, an agency wouldn’t sign her for fashion), and Allison doesn’t have chiseled bone structure- in fact only angelea does- along with the thinness, long legs and photogenic and refined features one needs. I think Laura could be signed by a commercial driven agency, Allison could be signed by a quirky, smaller and avante-gaurde agency and Lisa…uh..nothing. And arrogant obnoxious Lisa thinks she won because she’s simply the sh*t when she won by default. She’s delusional if she thinks she should’ve won based on ability or “personality”- she thinks personality is measured by how loud, arrogant and stupid you are and in my book, that just measures how big of an idiot you are. In reality, Allison is the smartest and most interesting so SHE in fact had the personality.

December 11, 2011 at 9:33 pm
(188) Broding says:

What’s being overlooked is the girls ACTUAL modeling potential. If the final four girls were put in front of The president of IMG, Lisa and Laura would be out automatically (and even would be discouraged to not even COMe to an open call) because lisas way too old and lauras way too short to do fashion (adorable though- shed be a good commercial girl), Allison isn’t the mist versatile and then they’d look at Angelea, put together a test shoot and would most likely sign her. She has everything the REAL industry wants: very thin, chiseled bone structure, long legs, beautiful features and can be easily transformed. She can have a real career if she tries- Lisa has no chance at a big modeling career- it’s laughable to think that could happen. We’ll see how full of herself she us when she can’t book a single runway show or beauty work.

December 11, 2011 at 11:31 pm
(189) bobbieholiday says:

Angelea is gorgeous, nevertheless shes way too hood, she cant control her mouth, so the whole leakage situation on facebook is a clear indication that she couldnt handle the title. She wasnt very professional and it seemed like she couldnt turn it on, off,left or right….its about following the rules…and she couldnt even do that…cause her mouth was to big…HOWEVER Allison should have won… JUS CAUSE…she was dope

December 11, 2011 at 11:55 pm
(190) Sharilynn says:

I’m not sure how I feel about Angelea being disqualified, or if it makes Lisa’s win less authentic, but I do believe Angelea should have kept her confidentiality agreement.

December 12, 2011 at 1:38 am
(191) ANTM Fan says:

If in fact Angelea was the original winner but she violated her contract it’s unfortunate but she has to suffer the consequences of elimination. She is very beautiful with allot of talent, but a contact is a contract binding and legal. I hope she will get a chance to redeem herself though and she will move on to bigger and better. As for Lisa, the crown now belongs to her and I wish her well.

December 12, 2011 at 1:52 am
(192) gypsie says:

just finished watching the finale…. u could totally tell they reshot that last scene! i kno if lisa wouldve won fo reals she wouldve freaked out n jumped around n screamed around! lol come on its lisa?! plus allisons hair was significantly shorter

December 12, 2011 at 5:19 am
(193) snowman says:

Honestly Angelea should have left the competition ages ago, her photoshoots were overrated and to be honest I think the judges had some “soft spot” for her because she kept banging on her “upbringing” I came from a very normal neighbourhood, very normal white parents who abused me also, it happens, doesn’t mean youve got to take a bad photo though. I am soooooo glad she got disqualified.

December 12, 2011 at 11:34 am
(194) Trish says:

I say by right Angelea won, no Lisa should not have been (given) the win she didn’t earn it. She displayed a very strong dislike towards Angelea, she picked and poked constantly at Angelea which made her unattractive in my opinion. Lisa displayed her fear that Angelea was a winner by her constant bad mouthing of Angelea, I pray hat Angelea gets picked by a top notch modeling agency and work the run ways all over the map, Lisa you shouldn’t display that ugly ragging on on character ever again all because you will cause your beauty to be fast forgotten, learn to lift others up by doing so you will reap greatness. Good Luck to all who go for their dreams.

December 12, 2011 at 12:28 pm
(195) m says:

Bottom line on ATM…. None of these girls or any other girls from any of the ATM seasons have ever become A TOP MODEL. The show is ridiculous. In the fashion world, on the runways everywhere,the models are usually not in their late twenties or early thirties when they BEGIN modeling. This is becoming a joke! It’s embarrasing.

December 12, 2011 at 12:40 pm
(196) cathy says:

Yes, she should have been disqualified. A contract means something. She blew it. I think Lisa would have won anyway because Angelea was too emotional and blew up way too easy. Models like that don’t make it. People don’t like working with them. Lisa won it fair and square. She listened to the judges and worked hard to improve herself. She is very talented in all areas. Was she my pick? No, I wanted Allicat to win it, but when I realized the sun was truly bothering her I figured she was out…and interviewing for Extra takes more personality than she has. She is quirky and unusual and will make it on her own.

December 12, 2011 at 1:36 pm
(197) MA says:

I agree with Chewy…May be Angelea is not such an Idiot! She will be talked about longer than Lisa…The girls that have won in the past I have not heard from since they won..unless they appear on the show again…I think Lisa should not have won…

December 12, 2011 at 5:41 pm
(198) coco says:

Stay off FACEBOOK. Facebook cost Angela a LIFE TIME opportunity. Let this be a lesson to everyone.

December 12, 2011 at 6:04 pm
(199) coco says:

Angela was always crying and talking about her past, so when you had a chance to change it all, you goes on facebook. Apparently, you like the way you were living. Its your fault.

December 12, 2011 at 7:09 pm
(200) jag says:

I hate tyra and I will never watch her again for doing that!!!!!!!!!!!

December 12, 2011 at 8:56 pm
(201) Kalie says:

I never liked Angelea. so im glad she was disqualified! That way someone more deserving and worth looking at would get the win.

December 12, 2011 at 9:25 pm
(202) Tatti says:

Angelea deserved to win more than anyone. she should have kept her mouth shut but she deserved to win. she had heart even if she did cry a little. Lisa did not deserve anything. She was waaaaay to cocky. Next ANTM pick Allison or someone who really deserves it.

December 13, 2011 at 12:20 am
(203) Eve says:

I totally agree with poster 134 DM: I would think that in addition to beauty, runway and photo challenges, Ms. Banks would desire her models to enbody a high level of taste and intellectual training, exposure to the arts with a wide reputation of culture, accomplishments, refinement, knowledge, sophistication, manners, class, elegance, grace, taste, a true attempt for civility and common courtesy.

Angelea did not represent any of these traits nor was she a front runner in ANY of her photographs or did she have a strong runway walk. Instead, she made fodder for classless reality TV that all producers love. Angelea reflected unsophistication, coarseness, crudeness, vulgarity, lack of manners and values and an overall horrendous, (and loud!), “feel sorry for me” attitude. In additon,
Lisa was a train wreck, and a loose cannon. Is this truly the person you want to represent ANTM “All Star” and all that title should stand for?
I would like to add that Laura was the total package for ANTM. She had great pictures, great personality, and would have been a great role model to young women everywhere! This was also evident in her cycle when Nicole won the title.

December 13, 2011 at 1:42 am
(204) Breeze says:

I think it’s a shame Angelea got disqualified for making a simple mistake like that. I think she had the ability to actually win and I could believe that she actually DID win originally but… rules are rules, they ALL signed a confidentiality contract and they all knew better. With that said, I think Lisa won fair and square… I don’t think she won by default, I think she won by following the rules, something Angelea COULD have done but didn’t…

December 13, 2011 at 5:56 am
(205) mb7k says:

WOW “Britknow”!! Tell us how you REALLY feel! (lol). Nevertheless, I really appreciate your comments most of all, since you have been in the industry for so long and know it inside and out.

I had been pulling for Angelea for the whole cycle because, in addition to being stunningly beautiful and a really good model, she was VERY entertaining. I belive that, had she won, she would have had agents and handlers and Tyra herself to help “refine” her, and round those rough edges. Certainly she would have begun to control her mouth better.

Again, “Britknow”, you hit the nail on the head when you alluded to Lisa’s age. I distinctly remember on Cycle 5 that the judges told Lisa that she was “photographing too old”. So, if she was photographing old on Cycle 5, how was she photographing on Cycle 17!!. This cycle, she was HEAVILY made up–something that was severely frowned upon in previous cycles. It’s sad but true. This industry is youth-oriented, which will give Lisa an uphill battle.

I don’t know where the ANTM show will go from here. Without a doubt, the fans were disrespected there at the end! I mean look at this backlash!! Though I am a male, I do love the show because it’s entertaining to see how the ladies react when put in the “pressure cooker”–quite a lesson in human nature. So, I would miss it, if it goes off of the air.

I hope that you are right. I hope that Angelea turns all of this free publicity completely to her advantage. It probably was a wise career move for her to cancel the New York news conference. You don’t want to “trash” the ANTM show, which is responsible for your fame. (AND YOU ARE FAMOUS, Angelea!!!!) This kind of publicity is rare. Use it right, and it could turn into MILLION$ of dollars!

I want to see Angelea walk the TOP runways of the WORLD!!!

December 13, 2011 at 10:23 am
(206) bev says:

In my opinion, if you want to destroy your modeling career then go on ANTM. Where are all of the other top models, including Eva, everyone’s favorite. Tyra chooses models according to her likes, not the public’s. She makes sure that none of the girls could quite out shine her and then she talks all that garbage about true beauty. Yeah, right. After this fiasco with Angelea I will not watch ANTM. I believe Angelea will do better on her own. She just has to believe in herself, which I believe she did by the end of the cylce. Word to the wise, if you want a “true” modeling career, never go on ANTM. Tyra’s so called magic touch for models is the same as Diddy’s so-called magic touch for singing groups. Have you seen any he’s sponsored lately. Nope.

December 13, 2011 at 12:14 pm
(207) mrp says:

Everyone commenting about her leaking the info-that all came from rumors. Of course the ending was re-shot, Tyra said so, the info came to them AFTER production had wrapped up, so it was necessary to do the judging in LA a second time. What’s interesting is that Nigel clearly stated that Angelea GAVE THEM information that disqualified her, and that the judges were sounding very sympathetic and wishing her the best. My theory is this: Angelea was crowned the winner in Crete, then several months later after production had finished Angelea informed them that she had been diagnosed with some illness/disease that would prevent her from following up on her win. For example CANCER. It fits: Angelea gives them info, her appearance will be affected, judges sympathetic, she wants privacy. Who knows?

December 13, 2011 at 10:23 pm
(208) blub.blub. says:

WOW. If the rumors are true then she is so dumb. She is really dumb. Fo’ real. Well, they might not be true. What is TRUTH?.. This whole season and contreversy has caused me to think very deeply…rethink about life..love..and the pursuit of happyness. :) Well, it’s better than me going super rage with this keyboard IN ALL CAPS. ANGELEA SHOULD HAVE WON!!! AAAAHHHHH!!!! ALLISON HAS PRETTY EYE BALLS!!!! >:( ANGELIE COULD HAVE CANCER!!!! WAHHH!!! BACKLASH IS A COOL WORD!!!!!!!!!! ;0 :) 8D.. I am a huge fan of top model and have been watching it with my mom since I can remember, and I don’t think this will effect me watching it next season (if there is one). I just love looking how everyone else percieves the episodes (especially the ones with drama )Okay, I believe I have said enough. :)

December 14, 2011 at 12:09 am
(209) Krissy says:

Allison should have won!!! Everyone knows that!!

December 14, 2011 at 5:18 pm


December 14, 2011 at 8:20 pm
(211) Uncletony says:

Angelea should have been crowned the winner, and if they had to pick a runner up it should have been Allison. Sorry Lisa but you are just commercial and there’s nothing wrong with that!
I am a little disappointed with the process!!

December 14, 2011 at 8:47 pm
(212) Nelly says:

I think it’s fair, she shouldn’t never opened her big mouth, Allison should’ve won!!!

December 14, 2011 at 8:59 pm
(213) Diane says:

I saw a lot of this season, and Lisa was the best one. I’m glad she got the title even if she was second choice.

December 14, 2011 at 9:04 pm
(214) Shanice says:

Angelea was cheated, yes she did make a mistake butshe worked and she should have won. Lisa should feel good about the win knowing angelea was the original winner. I pray that angie receives a bigger blessing then that contract, in my eyes she is the winner.*TEAM ANGELEA*

December 14, 2011 at 9:05 pm
(215) Shanice says:

Angelea was cheated, yes she did make a mistake but she worked and she should have won. Lisa should not feel good about the win knowing angelea was the original winner. I pray that angie receives a bigger blessing then that contract, in my eyes she is the winner.*TEAM ANGELEA*

December 14, 2011 at 9:26 pm
(216) GQ says:

Angelea never won she got disqualified for sleeping with the game after recording the video. Allison should have won

December 14, 2011 at 9:45 pm
(217) boobokitty says:

What part of “sign on the dotted line” did Angelea not understand? Her life was hard, as she repeated over and over and over again throughout the show, yet the girl done gave it away. Her fault. She lost because of integrity

December 14, 2011 at 10:30 pm
(218) ABR says:

According to Lisa, after she was voted to be sent home during her cycle (8), which I personally thought was unfair–she should of stayed over Jaeda– she was asked by the producers something to the effect:”What do you think your mother will say? ” This because Lisa was very vocal about the fact that she and her mother had always had major issues. Her mother’s boyfriend had molested her and her mother didn’t take it seriously, etc. To come back after that and just all she had gone through with being an alcoholic, and WIN was quite something. And I guess that had alot to do why she did win too over Allison (who I thought was going to win). But in regard to Angelea, as the saying goes,”never count your chickens before they’re hatched.” If you violate a contractional thing-a-majig there are consequences…and she really did want to win !

December 14, 2011 at 10:40 pm
(219) fashionchk says:

Allison should have won hands down.. angelea cried to much and Lisa is only pretty in pics. Otherwise she average if that. Allison is the prettiest girl they have had on the show and deserved it

December 14, 2011 at 11:46 pm
(220) diva says:

oh wow she was soooo stupid !!!! if that is the truth she has gone tho all this to GIVE IT AWAY lmao that’s what u get !!!!

December 14, 2011 at 11:51 pm
(221) diva says:

if her stupid but gave it away like that…..she didn’t really want it lmao thats what u get Angelie if that is true. u went through all that to do what….GIVE IT TO THE NEXT PERSON and u said u was in it to win it…. i cant tel. you know they hve a confidentally clause in the contract

December 15, 2011 at 12:00 am
(222) Becca says:

Why isn’t anyone here rooting for Allison? She is stunning, unique, classy, and likeable. I think Lisa looks like Barbra Streisand. And she looks OLD. Angelea was a mess. Pull it together, girl!

Allison had great shots, she was teachable, kind (including to all the other girls, which would require huge amounts of patience), and HER EYES are amazing! Go Allison! Angelea, whatever happened with the disqualification, it was meant to be. You should have been sent home weeks and weeks ago.

December 15, 2011 at 3:58 am
(223) Ead says:

I really do not like Angelea so I am glad she did not win. Even though I am an Allison fan, I think Lisa deserved the win and fit best for what they were looking for as an “all-star”.

December 15, 2011 at 8:04 am
(224) Dora cockfield says:

I really felt that Angelia would win or Allison I never even consider Lisa because she looks really old without all of the dramatic makeup and win Allison couldn’t open her eyes due to sunlight I knew then she would not win and then they cut to commercial and reveal that Angelia was disqualified without any explanation? what the hell, Lisa are you serious Tyra america got it right you guys got it wrong!!!

December 15, 2011 at 9:13 am
(225) rusty says:

lisa is not remotely modelesque – background is irrelevant
angelea was a little less ugh – again, background=IRRELEVANT
allison had overwhelming fan love and ACTUALLY IS A MODEL

December 15, 2011 at 12:02 pm
(226) rochelle lockhart-walker says:

they did another vannessa williams – she fouhgt hard and won hard so let her receive her reward

December 15, 2011 at 6:00 pm
(227) TabbyKat says:

I think it was fair. Contracts always say in less rude words, “KEEP YOUR TRAP SHUT!!” I know she was excited, but you have to keep it hushed. I’m dying to know what it really was, but then again it’s non of our business ( but I wish it was ;-} ) She violated a contract rule so she forfitted her chance. I hope she learned from this and will never do it again. Besides we’ll most likely see her again because she has Drive and perseverance. I don’t think that she won because she struggled this whole competition. She was in the bottom 4 times, but maybe the judges did see something in her, I guess we’ll never know. However i do have to say that she is not as consistent as the other 2. I personally am an Alli~Kat, Laura, and IsIs fan, but Lisa is awesome in her own right and she deserved her win. Good job Lisa!

December 16, 2011 at 10:58 am
(228) Cee says:

Lisa is the most talented; glad she won!

December 16, 2011 at 3:05 pm
(229) Jessica says:

If Angelea was the original winner she should have kept it under wraps as she was told, it is her own fault she was a blabber mouth and therefore was disqualified. I am honestly glad she did because I would have stopped watching ANTM had she won. I don’t feel like Angelea ever deserved to win. She never won a challenge until the last one, week after week her pictures sucked until towards the very end of the competition, and to top it all off she just downright had a bad attitude. She lost control of herself and her emotions at the drop of a hat and I don’t think you should have a loose cannon on set or trying to be a role model for young girls.

Lisa did not win by default. She really deserved to win because she was the best of the best. She had it all…the walk, the pictures, the acting, the music, the personality, etc. This season of ANTM was all about having that triple threat, that extra something that made you special and memorable, and Lisa had it.

But to be honest I wasn’t all that happy with the final 3 to begin with. I think Lisa should have been there, but Angelea and Allison should not have. I like Allison alot, she is such a sweetie, she is gorgeous, and takes great pictures, but I just think her eyes were going to be too much of an obstacle at times. I think Dominique and Laura should have been in the final 3 with Lisa. But I am not an ANTM judge.

But wouldn’t that be a cool spin on things, if Tyra Banks had like two surprise judges next season that were real viewers of the show. I think we know what makes a good model and what people like. Congrats Lisa!

December 16, 2011 at 11:28 pm
(230) joe franco says:

she should have won anyway. if the judges liked her, then she is a winner. no model is perfect. its all about what they sell (clothing, makeup etc.). every model has different personalities and their own way of standing out.

December 17, 2011 at 2:24 am
(231) tnmn42 says:

Comes down to trust and contracts. These reality TV shows review the contracts, terms, and confidentiality agreements and you sign on the dotted line knowing this.
Why would you do that??? What if they hired her to do Victoria Secret fashion show and after rehersals she blabs about all the secrets. Bottom line, you lie you lose. She was told to keep quiet, she didn’t.

December 17, 2011 at 2:44 am
(232) Debra says:

To all you hatter’s out there, if in fact Angelea broke the contract in any way she deserved to be disqualify! She was a beautiful YOUNG lady who may or may not have made a mistake, however, Lisa also is a beautiful YOUNG lady who has made mistakes, and has learned from them! She no longer drinks or uses Drugs and will be a wonderful role model for girls wanting to go info modeling!

December 17, 2011 at 9:18 pm
(233) Eva says:

Team Allison !!!! Allison got robbed ! She was so Gorgeous and talented! If anything the top 3 should have been Allison, Laura, and Dominique. Lisa was a masculine drunk, and angelea was a very bad model, age got lucky in every photoshoot! I think the judges keep people on the show for drama rather than taker and it’s disappointing to see true talent go home. Also Allison was the only one on the show with true interest in modeling and fashion … Lisa was all about her music career and this was just a way to get her name out there. This show should keep focus on the modeling aspect, otherwise it will get lumped in with all the other trashy reality shows!

December 18, 2011 at 7:01 am
(234) Nate says:

Its obious that it was a reshoot. Both allison and lisa didnt seem excited and the deleberation was extreamly short. Angelea probably won but she sucked as a model anyway. It should have been Allison. She is drop dead georgeous and takes really good pictures. Her walk isnt too good but that gets better with practice. Lisa is too loud and cocky. The lony reason why she addressed that she wasnt overly cocky in the reshoot was because so many people kept syaing that about her, She sucked. Oh well in the end Allison will shoot to stardom

December 19, 2011 at 11:35 am
(235) Fun says:

Allison would be great for Vogue, she is so extraordinary. And I wouldn’t mind if Laura would win, Loveable and Beautiful!!!

But not Lisa!!! She looks like she is 40!!!! And what’s up with her nose? She needs a rhinoplasty!!!!!!

December 21, 2011 at 12:46 am
(236) Dyz says:

ALISON SHOULD HAVE WON! outraged.. i swear every season of antm the girl i want to win NEVER WINS! so mad. so so so mad!

December 22, 2011 at 12:40 am
(237) Changis says:

It was pretty messed up that Angelea was disqualified bc she posted something on FB. That’s a pretty stupid reason. I was a very big fan of Tyra Banks and i thought shed do something to give Angelea another chance but i doubt she even tried. Angelea should have taken it home! The judges and ANTM production people were pretty unfair!

December 22, 2011 at 12:18 pm
(238) Shannon says:

I don’t think any of you have the right to say Lisa did not win. Nobody knows Angelea won. Lisa or Alison could’ve won and Angelea could’ve revealed it, therefore she would’ve been been disqualified and the ending re-shot without her. And at the least, nobody knows if her “spilling the beans” was the real reason.

December 22, 2011 at 1:09 pm
(239) barbie says:

Sometimes we forget that the show is all about Tyra. She nurtured Angelea for every episode and there was a running dialogue with her and her feelings. Tyra said that she best portrayed the book that Tyra wrote.
Angelea is not an elegant, lovely, model, but a cursing, crude, domineering wretch who doesn’t belong on any program. She is a bad example for other young women because she brags, curses, and is unprofessional in trying to get her own way.
Allison was lovely, and was set up to lose. Why were there so many shots in the direct sun? You’ll find out that this was another set-up for whatever reason.
I’m tired of Tyra’s cutesy distractions, and I’m so sick of the program that I’m not going to watch it any more.

December 22, 2011 at 1:13 pm
(240) barbarita says:

Sometimes we forget that the show is all about Tyra. She nurtured Angelea for every episode and there was a running dialogue with her and her feelings. Tyra said that she best portrayed the book that Tyra wrote.
Angelea is not an elegant, lovely, model, but a cursing, crude, domineering wretch who doesn’t belong on any program. She is a bad example for other young women because she brags, curses, and is unprofessional in trying to get her own way.
Allison was lovely, and was set up to lose. Why were there so many shots in the direct sun? You’ll find out that this was another set-up for whatever reason.
I’m tired of Tyra’s cutesy distractions, and I’m so sick of the program that I’m not going to watch it any more.

December 22, 2011 at 5:25 pm
(241) Ueno says:

I think Allison should have won…hands down. If the judges had any clue about the future, they would see that Allison could be the “Next Twiggy” but noooo. Let’s give it to the ex-rehab, psycho, over the hill, dark Lisa. Who will probably end up back on the pipe, while Allison, who has so much talent, will eventually be discovered by a new, hip and fun agency.

One can only hope. Hang in there Allison. You have more support than you would believe.

December 26, 2011 at 9:23 pm
(242) Kelley says:

If this is even true… The piont is… The girl can’t even keep her word. Which makes her undeserving of any Top position… The winner is the winner… which is Lisa. The End.

December 26, 2011 at 9:33 pm
(243) nabilah says:

but then again the reshoot doesnt mean that angelea won. it can be a reshoot to show that she was disqualified before the final judging since the actual shoot still have three people. so lisa could have won the thing in the first shoot, and shoot again just for the sake of not having angelea in the same room. ngeh. i dont mind lisa winning. both of them improved and both was strong and never whine about the competition. well not tht i know off. lalala

December 27, 2011 at 6:08 pm
(244) Sharon says:

Lisa defiantly won by default. I wouldn’t want it if I wasn’t number 1.

December 27, 2011 at 10:41 pm
(245) valarie h says:

I knew Angelea was gonna take it all, i think she was disqualified cause the network thought it would be bad for ratings for a ghetto girl from Buffalo to take it all, when it all actuality it would have sent a great message to millions of young girls like her. Coming from that ackground it would e hard for anyone to hold that! Great job Angelea, I knew you would go all the way and in my eyes you are ANTM All Star! keep dojng what you do. Tyra I love you but you should have fought for her to stay.

December 29, 2011 at 6:02 pm
(246) Alicia says:

I thought angelia was kind of a diva but I can’t stand lisa and there’s no way that ugly bitch should of won. angelia was better in every way. I’d rather have a diva then an annoying little kid. angelia the true where in my eyes

January 1, 2012 at 10:28 pm
(247) Diva says:

I do not know what some of you are speaking on because Lisa was more ghetto than any girl on the entire show!! please give me a break, Angelique should have won period!!! Also, none of you are perfect, just saying

January 2, 2012 at 3:21 pm
(248) Jesse says:

she was probably pregnant!! which would totally explain why she was sooo crazy half the time and emotional. and if she was then of course they wouldnt want her to be the winner. not only is she a bad influence but the creators and editors of the magazines she signed with would have to deal with her pregnancy and no one wants a emotional pregnant lady to sell eye shadow.. i dont know if this is true but it would totally make sense and no one should be saying anything about lisa not being worthy of her win because only few people know what really happened so we WOULDNT know a fair punishment. lisa is a role model and deserves the win she got. obviously sense angelea did something to screw up her own chances. thats her fault and no one elses.

January 3, 2012 at 1:22 am
(249) Taylor Sabia says:

allison should have won! she’s so cute and SO much more better. Angelia and Lisa shouldnt have won either way

January 3, 2012 at 4:47 am
(250) CiCi says:

None of you know who “Originally Won” so shut up, I don’t think you were present when they made the choice. And there is no way we can determine whether or not Angeleas disqualification was fair or not, because we don’t know ANY facts about what really happened.

January 3, 2012 at 12:39 pm
(251) su says:

lisa really sucked she looks like a tranny and who cares if she leaked the info she was not telling any lies so she should have still won. as for lisa she shouldnt feel special nobody wanted her thats why they chose angelea OBVIOUSLY!!!!!

January 6, 2012 at 10:26 am
(252) America'snexttopmodelfreak says:

Now listen to me and listen welll, My girl Angelea should have walked away with that title… That girl have came a long way and would be a positive role model to the African American girls that are currently struggling…. Tyra of all ppl should know, because she didn’t have it easy… Not tell me what example Lisa is setting???? Oh i guess CRAZINESS is the key to success. Stupse!!!!!!!!!.. Anyways Angelea your my girl and I would always support you… I done watch that lame show call ANTM… PS I hate it.

January 6, 2012 at 2:37 pm
(253) Mel says:

Allison should have won… or they should’ve brought Laura back and made her the winner. Angelea obviously wasn’t ready for this and Lisa is crazy and annoying. Not poised and interesting like Laura and Allison. Lisa is fake!!

January 11, 2012 at 1:55 am
(254) enlighten says:

I see, Dam i was on Ange’s said from the start. yea she bugged me with the crying abit but out of everyone i did see her with the most potential. I’m not sure if she actually won it but if she did it would make sense, i goggled y she was disqualified after seeing the final and i kept thinking y does this final judgeing seem like the most anticlimatic compared to all the other season ANTM winners. If it was because she acutally won and Lisa who is so energetic knows in reality she lost, it would explain that kind of depressing atmosphere during the season. Dam dam dam ange if u really talked than dammit if that wasnt just dumb….

January 12, 2012 at 12:00 am
(255) Rebecca says:

It may sound crazy but part of me felt sooo hurt and disappointed when i found out she didnt win or didn even have a chance to have her pictures and catwalk evaluated. i was rooting for her and when i saw her feel low and doubt herself in the competition my heart went out for her and made me want her to win even more just so she could see how made for antm all star she was. i felt like her winning would have been the real making of her. i already knew just by the action of her not being allowed to have her portfolio evaluated against the other girls that hers was stronger and that she clearly won. However Lisa would have been my second option too. she has come through very hard times and i rate her highly. she did not use her past as an excuse or make her past struggles as obstacles. i fell inlove with the girl that was not perfect though (angelea) lisa was too perfect but i saw myself in angelea and thats wot sell relatability. its such a shame a minor silly move is what stole that from her. we all make mistakes doesnt mean u should have teared away her dreams.

January 14, 2012 at 10:33 pm
(256) Kathy says:

Lisa should have been the winner. She put forth 100% for every challenge and won several challenges. She never complained. She was talented all the way around. Good for Lisa.

January 15, 2012 at 4:27 am
(257) Bunson Burn says:

Angelea was NOT the crowd favourite actually. The thing that annoyed me most about her was when the other girls were trying to give her constructive criticism to help her overcome her own self confessed (self doubts, fears and self esteem) she wouldnt even listen she just went all stupid and started name calling. Its SO immature.

The final show was a complete let down, you watch all season looking forward to a grand finale, only to come back after the ads with a quick lame reason why they’re back in L.A and an anti-climax announcement of the winner in front of 2 girls who both look unimpressed as if they already know the outcome!


January 19, 2012 at 11:09 pm
(258) Spewsleonel says:

I’m sure the best for you rip dvd to mp3 for less for promotion code

January 22, 2012 at 12:48 pm
(259) cassandra says:

Angelea, may have won it but she was never emotional’y stable to keep it,

January 29, 2012 at 10:50 am
(260) Chee says:

Good thing she has big mouth and was disqualified..

I prefer Laura… She really is lovable.

February 8, 2012 at 7:53 pm
(261) Bruna says:

Lisa has great looks and awesome personality. She really deserved it.
Allison is also very cool, I would also be happy if she’d won.
Angelea was so angry all the time, and kept arguing with the girls, she wouldn’t even listen to what they had to say.
She was very unreasonable and weak.
I really wish she hadn’t been disqualified and lost anyway! =)

February 16, 2012 at 3:34 pm
(262) Verona says:

Although Angelea broke her contract with ANTM, she was the Winner of the Alstar cycle.
Excuse me if while I get sick just thinking that a classless person like Lisa can be touted as the winner by default! Yeah, lets show some model class by peeing your pants, oh that’s real classy. And then put yourself in a bathtub and look absolutely hideous in front of millions of people and TV viewers.
Angelea had her bad moments but never once did she lower her standards to Lisa’s.
In my books they should not have given out the title when Angelea was disqualified. The title will always belong to Angelea, broken contract or no, Lisa was second and will always be second!

February 19, 2012 at 3:40 am
(263) owenwells says:

Angelea’s a big petty insecure bitch

February 19, 2012 at 5:51 am
(264) Ed says:

I think America’s Next Top Model All Star should have been Allison. she has amazing bug blue eyes. i’ve got big blue eyes to and i rarely wear makeup. even on that rare occation i stick will not very bright colors, browns usually. if allison was selling a product i would wear it. Lisa may have had a troubled child hood… did anyone take into concideration allisons father dying… no they did not… so lisa’s troubled back round should not be concidered… ik that sounds mean but it should be fair… also lisa looks like everyother model out there while its not everyday you see a model with huge adorable blue eyes!
I vote it should have been allison who won America’s Next Top Model All Star!!!

February 19, 2012 at 9:06 pm
(265) Luther says:

I agree with Ed. Allison is the best among all the other contestants. She even won the “Extra” challenge. She is a true artist not like Lisa who is obviously trying to hard.

March 7, 2012 at 4:46 am
(266) caro says:

Allison should have been the one!

March 14, 2012 at 8:22 pm
(267) pewshaws says:

I’m sure the best for you cocktailkleider.blinkweb.com/ online shopping Kleid0315

March 23, 2012 at 5:11 pm
(268) Andrea says:

I think she should have been kicked off also . If there was an agreement and she broke it thats wrong . I have a hard time believeing that Ang was going to win that . I can’t believe she even made it to the top 3 . I liked her a lot but she was just not ready for that kind of competition . She needs to get rid of that The world is against me attitude

April 2, 2012 at 4:47 pm
(269) Jill says:

No she should have won. I really think they were wrong to take it away. Wish her all the best and hope she makes it big on her own

April 2, 2012 at 5:13 pm
(270) bev says:

when a person signs a contract of conditions and then breaks them of course they should be disqualified else what is the point in getting them to sign in the first place and if she is so quick to break the rules she is not a very good role model is she

April 2, 2012 at 7:03 pm
(271) Meg says:

I think Allison should have won personally. I thought all three finalists were so beautiful and amazing but Allison was my personal favourite. I’m not sure why Angelea got disqualified but I’m sure she didn’t deserve it. I still stand by Allison though and would love to see her in magazines and maybe even meet her! (:

April 3, 2012 at 5:26 am
(272) ANTM PEACE MAKER says:

Honestly, I don’t know how Tyra continued on through panel. I would have been crying because I’d feel so liberated. I love Angelea, she was feisty, ambitious and set herself high goals. She simply made the wrong decisions. If any of you people think hating on her is going to make you any better, you are highly mistaken. Each of the girls had unique aspects, why do you have to go highlighting their flaws?

April 3, 2012 at 9:25 am
(273) British-Flavour says:

As for Alison she is so sweet and i believe she will make it regardless as she has the talent and potential.
Firstly I believe all the models in every episode is amazing as it is hard to have the courage to go on television and do all the task knowing people all over the world is watching.

Secondly, in regards to the first “American All Stars” it was great Tara and all her colleagues have a great and artistic mind to come up with the whole show.
Lisa is nice but she keeps stressing all the way she want to sing so why did she come on the show in the first place, that’s puzzling as the judges did not take that in to account.
Nevertheless, good luck to them all.

April 9, 2012 at 6:28 am
(274) clare says:

Lisa won get over it

April 13, 2012 at 8:41 am
(275) John says:

Wow, so many racist people in here commenting, protected by vague comments and anonymous usernames. You guys are all so brave and really intellectual! I’m sorry you’re too ignorant to realize that Angelea may not fit into your Augusta golf clubs or stuffy, smokey back-rooms in your basement, but she clearly was the winner. Obviously something’s too fishy about this, who cares if she revealed the top 3. It’s a reality show, like so many of you have said, it’s not a presidential election. Jesus, you think she’d have shared military secrets the way some of you are responding. If you’re so bothered by her, maybe you should look at why that is. Why you need to hate on someone, especially someone who has had it rougher than you. Who are you in the grand scheme of things to hate on anyone, let alone someone who has to work 10 times as hard just to get to your level. You guys are beyond shameful, I’m embarrassed to have read a lot of these comments.

April 24, 2012 at 9:05 am
(276) Ulrika says:

I agree with Amber (3). Angelea was a wreck she had never managed to win. Certainly it has been noticed that she has always been a favorite of Tyra Banks (been three times in Top Model and this season in the bottom four times!!) But she certainly was not the best in the Allstars. Angelea would never have come to the top three and she had never won. Lisa and Allison deserved to be in the finals! Lisa is a true entertainer and a good model – a real Allstar. The right person won!

I think they chosed to film the end of the reason that Allison went out and came third, actually, and that when Lisa and Angelea stood in the finals .. they got the film on for them to match! I´m sure about that!! :)

April 30, 2012 at 4:23 am
(277) CLay says:

Im glad they stuck to their guns and disqualified her! She broke the rules! Rules aren’t there to be broken, or bent! Angelea has too much emotional baggage and struggles to sustain. Lisa won fair and square. There is nothing out there to support that Angelea had originally won the ANTM all star title!

April 30, 2012 at 4:39 am
(278) GuitarGirl says:

If she signed an agreement and then broke her word, she was rightly cut, or doesn’t integrity matter anymore? Angelea was far too insecure, and i think she would have found the industry a real struggle. Perhaps it was a better outcome for her future emotional health.

Out of the two left, I really liked Alison’s different look. But I’m happy for Lisa. Good for her. As well as Alison, I really liked Laura.

May 3, 2012 at 8:47 pm
(279) Jaymie says:

I’m glad she didn’t win. can’t stand her. She always acted like she was better than the other girls, made a fool of herself when she did her “club” thing. I say thank God she didn’t win.

May 28, 2012 at 5:16 pm

Angelea should NEVER made it as far as she did. She acted completely unprofessional and had emotional break downs all the time. I loved Allison but Lisa really did deserve to win over all.

If you look at all the competitions and top photos Lisa clearly beats the other two. She has the attitude and spunk for it. If this was a normal episode of next top model maybe angelea would have a chance. But, she doesn’t have what it takes to be an ALLSTAR. I liked her to begin with but her attitude was too much and way too cocky. Lisa was cocky too, but, in a lovable way because I could tell how badly she worked her ass off and it just made me root for her more. Allison was adorable and completely surreal. I just wish Lisa and Allison could have both won :) They truly deserved it.

June 5, 2012 at 7:34 pm
(281) Fan of ANTM says:

I think Allison should have won. She has beautiful gorgeous eyes I ever seen. Her eyes may be health issue when it comes to bright lights & sun. An eye doctor wouldve have something to help her. Ive seen other models having to go to dentist to get their teeth fixed. Same thing.

June 6, 2012 at 1:20 pm
(282) a fan says:

Allison should have one

June 13, 2012 at 4:46 pm
(283) Evie says:

Laura should have been the winner..But,that was a season ago..the last season was really bad..can’t you find enough girls in America that are looking for their dreams to come true.

June 21, 2012 at 3:17 am
(284) Wicked says:

Don’t have to be a rocket scietist to understand that if you brake a contract you have to pay the price for it. Sorry guys, girls and everything between but, sometimes it’s good to use the brain. Beauty won’t last whole life and when you are to old/ugly you have to leave this kind of bizz. Then you most likely have nothing. And trust me, there are lots of really beautiful humans that have lots of brain and still humble.

June 22, 2012 at 8:51 pm
(285) Amanda says:

Listen there is a reason for the contracts and Lisa did not win by default. Angelea should of not done what she did! The right top 2 were the right ones! GO LISA!!!!!!

June 23, 2012 at 3:15 am
(286) dj says:

Angelea was way too unprofessional, crude, crass, unclassy, and close-minded to survive in the high fashion modeling world — maybe in a biker magazine.

June 23, 2012 at 4:11 pm
(287) julie searle says:

I watched all the episodes of top model season
eleven back to back. from the beginning Lisa was a standout and was not afraid to make creative descisions. I really liked Allison too. I liked Angelea and she proved she did have what it takes to be a Top Model. I think it was okay for her not to be liked by everyone. If she broke the rules it is a shame. However, Lisa will make a great top model and did have the whole package and did make you want to watch her.

June 25, 2012 at 3:31 am
(288) Julie says:

I just watched the whole season back to back, too. Why do people keep posting here about who they *think* should have won, and why? The question here is “What did Angelea do to get disqualified, and when did she do it?”

I’ve read that it is because she was pregnant, which I guess could make sense, but is that in your contract? That you can’t get pregnant? But that makes more sense to me than that b.s. about her posting the names of the final three on Facebook. That’s something Tyra et al could have addressed openly; her getting pregnant might be more difficult to talk about on the show.

It just seems too coincidental to me that she got disqualified in December, then found out in December that she was pregnant. I think it’s all related, and must be a no-no in the contract. Maybe it’s even that creepy male model’s baby!

July 12, 2012 at 3:50 am
(289) shun212 says:

I hope Angeles find success in her modeling career. People need to remembe that she’s. still young so she’s _
able to change her behavior. If she really wants to pursue a modeling career.

July 19, 2012 at 1:13 am
(290) lexy lopez says:

Personally out of the top 3 I think that allyson should’ve won because she is so beautiful and different and she’s a great model.

July 19, 2012 at 12:52 pm
(291) GIgi says:

I think “she” got disqualified for being a man in the past.

July 20, 2012 at 9:03 pm
(292) jafjdsfhn says:

She was such a bitch.. the only thing she could do right was critique.. She was terrible!!

July 21, 2012 at 2:05 am
(293) Laruen says:

I’m glad that she was disqualified.
She was rediculous in the way she portrayed herself.
She was constantly having mood changes which makes us all believe she is bi-polar,
She was not a good model.
Her pix were not worth seeing her in any magazine.
She paraded around like she was a queen and she looked rediculous especially in the perfume shoot.
This immature truely ugly personality should have never been called back.

I am a great fan of the quirky blonde who was so unique and gorgeous.

I’m glad Angelic is gone and not in our faces with that ugly face and horrible body anymore.


It was like watching a train wreck. ANGELIC THE TRAINWRECK!

July 21, 2012 at 2:08 am
(294) Laruen says:

“Angelea the train wreck.” Yes I also think she was a man.
She would never have been selected as the winner. She was horrible. Maybe she can get a job in the circus as a clown.

July 21, 2012 at 1:30 pm
(295) Meagan says:

I think the information had to have been released by Angelea several weeks back because there was a final 3 not final 2….I would venture to say that she revealed it right before the runway in Crete otherwise after the Covergirl commercial and shoot they would have narrowed it down to 2 then went from there. I would say that it was only because of the time, money and effort spent that they let Angelea do the runway show…that’s probably when the were doing their investigation into the reports. But you cant put a show like that on hold while you figure things out. And couldn’t leave her out just in case she didn’t actually do it. But she had to have….But Angelea didnt deserve it anyway, the big cry-baby. Should have been Dominique and if not then Lisa was the right choice!

August 7, 2012 at 4:45 pm
(296) Mia says:

I hate angel but luv Allison

September 21, 2012 at 2:53 pm
(297) DLD says:

I think Lisa was a better choice for the winner. Angelea was an awful role model for girls, she was really cocky and rude. But Lisa always kept her composure throughout the show. Yes it was fair than Angelea got disqualified, she broke the rules. Point Blank.

September 26, 2012 at 7:25 am
(298) lena says:

Am from kenya and i wish Angelea won, she is real.
hope all the best for her in the future….

October 1, 2012 at 1:37 pm
(299) GWCurls says:

Everyone needs to go back and re-watch the final show – or the one before it – where they were all getting ready for the fashion show – swimming under water and playing their song. In the back room before they went on Angelea actually says to Allyson that she let friends know or posted that they were the last 3. Allyson comments that she wasn’t supposed to do that – something like that. Go back and watch and you will see – and you also see Angelea crying her eyes out hoping she doesn’t get in trouble. She did post what she wasn’t supposed to. i was very sad for her – and silly girl what was she thinking. In the end i wanted allyson to win – but i was happy if it was Angelea too – just a shame how it all turned out. :(

November 4, 2012 at 12:26 am
(300) toni says:

When I saw Angelea feeling sick in the final episode I don’t know why I immediately thought she was pregnant. Then when she got disqualified it really got me thinking that the show found out she was pregnant and disqualified her. But then the rumor about her revealing winner on her fb came out and so I forgot my initial theory, only to see recently that she had a baby. Based on the timing maybe my theory was right after all…

November 23, 2012 at 8:09 pm
(301) Pepe Cortez says:

I feel the decision to disqualify Angelea was the correct one, regardless as to whether she won or not. All contestants had to adhere to the rules of the contest. Besides, she was not a strong candidate for finalist– she is too weak and emotional to be able to handle the pressures of being a professional model. Moreover, she did not present herself very well, too ghetto and a real train wreck personality wise. However, I wish her well and hope she makes the adjustments necessary to be successful in modelling because she is attractive and can do well with the right coaching and if she is willing to listen.

November 23, 2012 at 8:39 pm
(302) LADYANGEL says:

Hi, I think Lisa was fantastic but for me she was more an actor that a model. Alison was more a model and natural too. The title should it be for Alison. Because she was shy that was not a reason for her not to win. Alison is fantastic. Angelea broke the rules therefore she was disqualify which it was the right thing to do. I really hope the best for her but she needs to believe she have it in her.

December 10, 2012 at 3:27 pm
(303) Reality Check Sister says:

I honestly do believe that Angelea was perfect rag to riches story for young African-American girls looking to break into the industry. I looked up to her because in many ways she reminded of Bre from cycle 5. She had the personality, drive, and confidence it took to win.

Now with that being said, I do not believe that she deserve to win since she broke the rules. One thing that a lot of people do not realize about reality TV is that you have sign a contract stated what you are not allowed to do. If the contestant breaks any those rules then disqualification from the competition automatic.

I do not see any reason for anyone to get upset or mad at anyone other than Angelea. If she had read the contract then she would have known that revealing any of the result prior to the competition being over is a huge consequence. The moral of the story is to make sure you know exactly what you are agreeing to commit to so you don’t end up stepping across lines.

December 11, 2012 at 4:45 pm
(304) KaeRay says:

Plan and simple- Lisa did not deserve to win. Angelea and Allison were much better than her by far. It’s stupid. Who cares if she leaked it people are still going to watch it anyway.

January 10, 2013 at 9:22 pm
(305) sexyreere says:

One step forward 2 steps BLACK>>>>>>>

February 6, 2013 at 8:55 am
(306) Georgia says:

Angelea was the worst, most annoying, horrible contestant I think I have ever watched on ANTM.

Girls on reality shows need to stop using the things they have been through to make them seem more endearing to the judges and the public. Angelea went through this entire competition claiming that she was ‘real’, more so than all the other contestants. What does that even mean?

Angelea was vain, immature and held a ridiculous sense of superiority above the other girls.

She did not deserve to win this competition, and I am glad she didn’t.

February 21, 2013 at 10:09 am
(307) Sarah says:

You know what angelea thank god you posted that on fcebook cause I’m so glad you got disqualified I loved Lisa and Laura and Allison they should have been the top three and also you could see in Lisa’s race she did not seem very excited cause she new it was by default by why the hell would Tyra choose angelea thank god she posted that on Facebook or else she would have been the first America’s next top model all star Love you Lisa!!!

February 21, 2013 at 10:12 am
(308) Sarah says:

Thank god angelea posted that on Facebook or else she would have been he first America’s Next top model allstar I am really glad Lisa won all angelea did Is walk around and cry what was Tyra thinking to make her America’s next top model all star seriously thank god Lisa won but I wis Laura was at least in the top three congratulations Lisa and to all you hater that say give angelea a chance she screwed it up she told no one else did she ruined it for herself love you lisa

April 1, 2013 at 2:27 pm
(309) Lesbian says:

Angelea was disquilfied because she found out that she was pregnant. You can’t get pregnant win you sign a modeling contract.

April 6, 2013 at 9:28 pm
(310) RosaI says:

Makes sense… the pregnancy factor as a reason…such a good news… in such a bad time… hope everything ‘d be just fine for her and her son… :)

May 26, 2013 at 11:48 pm
(311) kewona chappell says:

She had it they played my girl she is happy in life she will be fine she is a strong young lady luv her.

June 28, 2013 at 4:54 pm
(312) kc says:

that is so sad i was wanting her to win and them girls really didn’t want her to win. she been through alto but when she was about to win they’re going to use that against her that is very wrong if that’s the case she should have never did all the cover girl things they mad her do at the end of the finals. that way i really don’t like watching Americas next top Model .she would have be my favorite ANTM. actually she is

(but she did now what she was getting herself into )

July 4, 2013 at 7:02 pm
(313) tim says:

no very unfair i think they should not have done that too her besides allison sshe was the best

July 7, 2013 at 4:50 pm
(314) Middman says:

I have ah are time beleiving she won to begin with. She was not worthy or deserving of the title. If she had won like some thought she had and broke the rules…she pays the consequences. The cot her contestants said she was unpredictable and so up and down. I was tired of seeing her pout and feel sorry for herself. She kept saying she deserved it and
Referred to where she had come from. Lisa came from a tough background and never used that as an excuse. Angelia’s shots were consistently poor. I had no respect for her at the end.

August 6, 2013 at 2:33 am
(315) Lauren says:

I think Angelea wasn’t very good anyway becuse she isn’t very professional if she is running off and b***ing every time something doesn’t go her way so maybe she had good photos but she wasn’t top model material if she is going to run off and cry every time something she didn’t like happened or when she has a bad day, also I loved both Alison and Lisa and they probably would have out won her anyway I think that the fact that they say angelea won is a lie becuse it wouldn’t be a smart move to crown angelea proffessionaly I wouldn’t hire angelea becuse when she has a bad day up instead of sucking it up she takes It out on other people so proffessionaly I would probably chose Lisa but I also love Alison the only problem is you can’t book someone who has sensitive eyes so I would over all in the most proffessional maner I would chose Lisa over any of the 3 girls

August 9, 2013 at 3:58 pm
(316) Barbara Anderson says:

I was hoping for “2″ of the gals to go on, and I did not care which one of the 2 won, as long as ONE of them did.
I was hoping for either Allison OR Laura. That show RIPPED OFF BOTH OF THOSE GALS…..100%. AND, once just wasn’t enough for them. They had to REPEAT it AGAIN. Poor Allison was put thru the MILL a bit MORE then Laura, however, no LESS painful for Laura.
Just MAYBE – Miss Tyra should be investigated as to just “WHAT WENT ON THAT DAY!!” I am SURE she HOLDS THE KEY to the WHOLE THING!!! AND, IF Angelea was to be chosen as the TOP MODEL….she should NOT have known about it, UNTIL IT WAS OVER, AND THE ACTUAL END CAME FOR THE “TELLING” TO THE WORLD!! This episode has sort of turned me a bit sour for watching the show. Yes, Lisa was good, BUT…..not as DESERVING AS LAURA OR ALLISON. I now BELIEVE that TYRA really DOES CHEAT and what a shame. But, IN THE END…..NOT “ONE” OF HER CHOICES FOR “AMERICA’S NEXT TOP MODEL” EVER MADE IT “ANYWHERE” IN THE BUSINESS!! Just look at where EVA ended up….SHE ended up on the “BAD GIRLS” show. Some “TOP MODEL” – hey??

August 9, 2013 at 4:04 pm
(317) Barbara Anderson says:


August 9, 2013 at 4:19 pm
(318) cleo says:

That chick didn’t have a chance in HELL of winner…

August 19, 2013 at 3:19 pm
(319) Josy says:

Allison should have won! She’s a beautifull star, a very special and unique woman!

August 30, 2013 at 2:00 am
(320) Cynthia says:

I just watched the re-run of the All Star cycle and for all of you people that are saying Anglea should of still won after breaking her contract should be ah shame of yourselves. A contract is a binding document and clearly she broke it. If she had of cost them and lost, she could have been sued, so she got off easy with them just taking the title. She got what she deserved, plus it’s obvious she couldn’t keep it together if she couldn’t keep it to herself that she won!!!

Leave a Comment

Line and paragraph breaks are automatic. Some HTML allowed: <a href="" title="">, <b>, <i>, <strike>

©2014 About.com. All rights reserved.