When American Idol 5 premieres in January, the show may be missing its most popular judge. That's right. Simon Cowell may be leaving Randy and Paula behind on American Idol. A New York Times article explains why Simon's contract negotiations and a certain lawsuit against him are making his future with American Idol unclear. Whether you love him or hate him, it's hard to imagine American Idol without the nasty, or should I say very honest, British judge. I will keep you updated on how this all plays out.

POLL: American Idol minus Simon Cowell equals: (Click on your answer to vote. )
1)One extremely boring show..
2)A pretty good show regardless.
3)An even better show without him.

View Poll Results